Siege Of Rohan OVER

[Squirrel2412 (David E)]

You are correct, there isn’t a rolelist.

It’s a closed setup, meaning players dont know the roles (other than the ones they have, of course)

[laserlab (William)]

it is good to know that nobody could possibly know that my role is dark lord sauron

[laserlab (William)]

I feel like I don’t need to explain this but this is a joke

[Nanook (Clem)]

@Andresvmb

I will consider this. I don’t actually mind the seriousness? What bothers me more than anything is people that think they’re good when they’re not.

Heh, you’d love it

[Nanook (Clem)]

@Andresvmb

No my counter argument is about the philosophical point, it’s not game specific. You’re still pushing this agenda and I get that but it’s looking worse from my POV. Dunya seemed to be making the point that I wouldn’t vote a new player as a matter of principle as Town (unless I’m Scum I guess). I said no, I am going to vote whoever I think is Scum, regardless of how new they are. How is this not a reasonable response?

Andres, I thought you didn’t like applesauce, but I saw you eating one, why?

Andres: I like apples in pie

Ok, were you eating apples in pie?

Andres: I’m not sure but I don’t think so

So…do you like applesauce?

Andres: I like apples in pie

Yeah…ok…but that isn’t really what I’m asking

Andres: my responses are reasonable and address your question clearly

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

Votecount as of post #300

GTacc (1): Esooa
Urist (1): Andresvmb
chesskid3 (1): dunya
dunya (1): Urist

Not Voting (9): laserlab, chesskid3, Ellibereth, GTacc, Nanook, orangeandblack5, Squirrel2412, Srceenplay, UFOFever

[laserlab (William)]

What do we get out of a D1 vote, it seems like an entirely random elimination which I guess is good because it narrows it down or (unlikely) eliminates a mafia person. Thinking about it we don’t know how many mafia there are, unless I am dumb and it says it somewhere.

[laserlab (William)]

In every game I have been in (ignore that this was two games) they have done it so I guess it is good

[Nanook (Clem)]

In the olden days we hit mafia d1 a significant amount of the time

[UFOFever (Derek)]

In the olden days I’m usually sheeping Elli by now so uhhhhh what the hell guys when did things change?

[laserlab (William)]

In the olden days I didn’t know about forum mafia

[Nanook (Clem)]

Eli is washed

[laserlab (William)]

Am I correct about my reasoning on why we vote d1?

[Nanook (Clem)]

Idk I wasn’t really paying attention

[Nanook (Clem)]

As long as you get to the conclusion that killing d1 is good then yeah sure

[laserlab (William)]

I don’t entirely get why but if everyone else thinks it is good then that is what is happening

[GTacc (Espresso GTacc)]

@Ellibereth

d a r t t h r o w i n g

Bloons td6?

[Squirrel2412 (David E)]

@laserlab

What do we get out of a D1 vote, it seems like an entirely random elimination which I guess is good because it narrows it down or (unlikely) eliminates a mafia person. Thinking about it we don’t know how many mafia there are, unless I am dumb and it says it somewhere.

I mean, no matter who it is, people are gonna take stances on the vote

And we can learn info based on the stances they took and how the person flipped

That’s my take anyways

[GTacc (Espresso GTacc)]

squirrel and laserlab are 2 different players? wat

[GTacc (Espresso GTacc)]

@laserlab

Did I miss something or is there no list of roles?

ok i believe you, you are town