I also think that people moving away from you and onto Nanook, who was Town, and quickly, is a bad sign. I’m convinced this is the case. If those players were Town, and they thought there was a case for one of the two of you, it would have taken longer, there would have been a discussion, and some people would have wavered. We got none of that. It was blatant. Again, one of you/Cats is almost surely Scum, if not both. Nothing you say will convince me this is not the case. So, I’m more interested in other people’s perspective, not really yours.
So basically, Town needs to step it up here and really come out with their views. I’ll just note that Erika hammered quickly - they must have seen a voter list that was particularly favorable to them. So that’s what concerns me the most - if MS is Scum, then we are in a real tough spot here. I’m not dead set on DS being Scum, and Cats is giving me the worst vibes right now, but DS openly questioning my view (when it’s entirely reasonable) tilts me further in that direction. Anyway, I’ll wait to see what other people have to say.
Day one was only one Real Day long.
I only had 30 posts and now Andre is claiming all this meta reading on me?
He is either scum or mixed up confused town.
My vote on Nanook was only the second vote to put pressure on him and suddenly he is lynched.
I have never played this type of game before, so live and learn.
Actually, yours was the third vote on Nanook - again, I moved my vote away, which is why your vote looks like a second vote. Very interesting you’re hiding behind this to justify your vote.
1 Like
You were also around and happy enough to announce that Nanook had been hammered, but didn’t seem at all concerned about the run up of votes on a player you were on. If you want to know what explains my view, this is it.
And I’m not confused at all.
I’m not hiding I am not justifying.
I am not remember yesterday (Real Time) play.
I am too tired, I have to much on and am not really very interested.
Much like you last game.
I had to reread my own thirty posts.
I was very much reading and following last game. And it was 2 Scum, which made it a lot harder, with a lot of roles. I wasn’t throwing around people as Scum now was I? And I also happened to be right at the end. So not sure I’m following what you’re saying.
Funny enough Andre.
The reason I am sus on you is because I have never seen you give a Meta Read before.
Cats is not ‘looking’ like town cats.
You have not picked out any posts that are scummy or analysed any part of my game.
Just said, it doesn’t feel right.
You’re Scum reading me? This is getting interesting.
Look at my actions. Anybody doubting where I’m coming from should be looking at them. I moved away from the player that was lynched who so happens to be Town, in a game where the Scum have an enormous incentive to ensure that the first player lynched is Town. Enormous. I would never move away from Nanook here if I’m Scum. Does not happen. And since I wasn’t on the wrong wagon, I have 0 incentive to try and lead the way and make myself a target. None. The vast majority of the times if I’m Scum and off wagon, I follow and not lead. Anybody thinking about this objectively can see this.
And it’s funny, me never giving a meta read is a clear and demonstrable falsehood. The first read I made of Nanook, in the game that just finished and that you played in, was a meta read, which you followed (it happened to be wrong).
Am I going crazy here?
See our exchange in #29 and #30 in Dengeki.
Good point.
Several good points actually.
About the Nanook wagon and the Meta read on Nanook in MS’s game.
I guess I just don’t like you reading me as scum from so few posts in such a short game.
And yes, now that you point it out, we both did the same with Nanook last game.
And we were wrong then and you are wrong this game about me.
I flagged right from the start of the game I am not going to have anywhere near as much time as I usually have.
My concern is that; this will give scum an excuse to lynch me as a lurker.
The argument is that all three scum where on Nanook?
That there can’t be scum in Metal and Andre?
Is this vote count right?
Andre is saying he would not have got off Nanook as scum.
I guess the argument that Redflavor ‘saved’ DS is a bit obvious?
Then drove the wagon on Nanook.
So this is What comes from wolf mindset^
VOTE: catspurr
What I’m arguing is that out of everybody left in the game, I am literally the least likely to be Scum. I can’t know for sure that the three Scum were on the wagon. Thinking about it strategically, it’s not the worst idea, but it’s not what I think is necessarily the most likely. But that, from my point of view, necessarily means that MS is Scum, and I’m not willing to go there yet.
Yeah I can understand that.
My problem is I am seeing a very analytical scum team.
They hammered knowing that they would have to sacrifice one scum that night.
The one who hammered was Erika, the one they sacrificed was Erika.
She was a goon, but then they are all goons aren’t they?
No powers in this game?
Okay, maybe not as carefully planned as it seemed.
I seem to have ended up agreeing we should lynch from the 4 left from the lynch.
Red, Catspurr, DS, or you.
Obviously I don’t think it should be me.:shrug:
VC 2-2
catspurr: 1 (very_unique_name)
Not Voting: 5 (RedFlavor, DS, Metal Sonic, Andresvmb, catspurr)
Deadline: November 20, 2018 4:00 AM
Note: Plurality Lynch rules are in effect.
I’m out for the day.
Got honest paying work to do.