Ranked Vengeful (Developing a rating system based on per game player ranking) Discussion

Archive Completed Signups
,
#162

I’m not sure there’s an elegant solution. Just say that getting lynched at 3p doesn’t lose points I guess? And like chess said, tying for last should be worse than getting 3rd alone. But I don’t think it should be the same as coming in 4th.

#163

@Ellibereth I saw that you were going to close the previous ranking and announce the final results. Where are they?

#164

It’s long. If everyone is locked in to her votes after 8h we shouldn’t have to wait another 40.
Secondly it essentially removes the opportunity to quickhammer as scum. I realize this is subjective and may not be considered a drawback to everyone.
That’s all I can think of right now. After a few games we’ll potentially see other issues with it.

#165

@tn5421 just waiting on you

1 Like
#166

maybe, talking people into changing their mind after they’ve “locked” etc.
we’ll see how it feels.

#167

@tn5421 just waiting on you for g2, if someone else wants to grab the slot lemme know.

#168

I’ll hop in @Ellibereth

1 Like
#169

Ah yeah I’ll do this ASAP. I’m fairly certain you had the best plus score.

#170

probably /in next so long as I don’t forget about this by then

or I can take tns slot :smiley:

4 Likes
#171

It’s been a while since we’ve seen Katsuki — their last post was 1 year ago

1 Like
#172

It has been quite some time.

IDK how I feel about not being allowed to state how votes on me triggers severe negative impact on my mental wellbeing though.

1 Like
#173

:gigathonk:

Probably going to split sign up and discussion in separate topics for my sanity/organization.

#174

@Ellibereth Why can’t we rank the Mafia’s Performance as individual members rather than as a team?

#175

Discourages playing as a team/doesn’t allow as much flexibility in how Mafia win.

#176

also potentially getting your partner killed/voted over you etc. to lower their score and raise yours which would be obviously unpleasant

1 Like
#177

Well then you can rank the Mafia by how well they do manipulating the town. Or wait, you don’t like doing a deep dive into what people do socially, never mind.

#178

you’re catching on :+1:

#179

Because apparently a Mafia who leads the town into disaster is just as great as one who nearly dies N1 and only by sheer luck wins the game.

#180

If you can present an algorithm to quantify what you’re talking about I’d be happy to take a look.

1 Like
#181

Soft data is just as good as hard data. You just don’t know how to mechanically process social interactions, so you act like they don’t exist.