Party Cop

Completed Games Completed Onsite
,
#441

damn, man

#442

I mean, I just feel like this game is a good example of why telling people the real reason why someone is scum is just a waste of time. Realistically you either have to railroad someone like happened to Chesskid or you have to get into the other players heads and try to figure out what they consider.to be scummy, and fabricate a case.

But anyway, the game felt unwinnable to me since day 1, so I was conceded for like the last 3 days of gameplay. (evident by my lack of attendance at the party)

1 Like
#443

if nobody had ever gone to the party it would have been pretty unwinnable for me tho

#444

Yeah, but the party was a given. The setup banks on it.

#445

Playing it as an open set up, it is unwinnable for mafia for sure.

1 Like
#446

i guess “you were wrong on chesskid” doesn’t really hold its weight for me as a reason why someone is bad. townies make mistakes? i just didn’t think it was a really solid case

#447

It’s not just being wrong.

#448

The real lesson here is you can only meme wagon and troll day 1 if you trust your reads later

#449

Also follow whatever chesskid said when he’s dead and flipped town because it’s fucking gold :slight_smile:

#450

I wonder how many people would join the party if we rerun this setup

#451

I mean, the GTacc read was obviously trash, but yeah, Urist flipping the RVS wagon (onto someone he believes is a stronger player) into a legit hard railroad based on 1 emogi despite anything and everything else you posted was outing (or should have been).

1 Like
#452

to be fair you did say to kill two townies before me

1 Like
#453

my preloaded response in case anyone actually asked would be to say that i thought this was a scumclaim considering the wording of the town role pm

1 Like
#454

@dunya to clarify see my last post, but I think part of reading Urist is that you have to consider if he thinks he’s making a good play. Sure the reads aren’t always accurate… That doesn’t really matter.

3 Likes
#455

Accurate

#456

But rude

#457

You were being rude. I conceded and you kept playing.

#458

nice. thanks for the tip! will come in handy for me in future!!

#459

something something hotel room

#460

That’s Ellibereth.