FoS: StarV
Tbh star is frustrating but this is a weird stance for scum to take right? Like why not just say “damn, thought he was scum!” and move on? Not sure scum really try to argue that the hammer was right and just and objectively correct tbh.
Thank you.
Frankly we probably suspect him either way I think this fits StarV’s careless meta better.
Which is probably why we’re getting this answer. If I gave you that answer you would think I’m surely Scum.
Sure but one argument is more likely to get traction/deflect enough to push suspicion elsewhere, while the other is…less likely.
Probably! But that’s cause I know it’d be disingenuous coming from you. Not sure it is from star? I don’t have offhand meta on whether he lolhammers only as one alignment though.
I just don’t get what Town is doing this game. After I ISO’ed Dusk I saw just how wrong we were. I don’t think anybody cared at the end and just lynched there. And now we have this situation where post-game if the entire wagon was Town I would be like yeah makes sense.
Like I want to think one of Tn/StarV has to be Scum but I don’t have any clue who to trust here and it’s driving me insane. This is like starting from scratch but in a much more heavily Scum-sided game.
I mean…yeah pretty much same tbh. Dusk seemed obvious town to me, I dunno wtf you guys were doing yesterday.
I would be surprised if there isn’t at least one scum on his kill though. Wouldn’t surprise me if it was town driven, but would shock me if that’s a totally pure wagon, cause I don’t know that you and tommy make sense as partners.
Yeah, I submitted Duskfall as my top town read last night, Elli was not impressed 
I’m going to have to just sit down and re-read all of D1 in light of the flips and try and figure out what’s going on. I don’t think restricting the next lynch to the Dusk wagon makes sense given how off a lot of us were throughout the day.
Unless you think scum was hard defending Dusk, then it should make sense FYPOV.
One Scum could have easily been doing this. And you’ve said that would fit your Scum meta. I could pull the post but you know what I’m talking about.
I’m not saying you’re Scum. I’m just saying - it’s totally not out of the question. I still think it’s more likely there was Scum on Dusk. Particularly after I got off. But that’s from my POV.
Sure, not saying you should clear me, just that you have to believe in a world where scum hard defended dusk to not kill on wagon.
And, like, even outside of dusk that’s a lot of TRs for scumNanook to have and fairly aggressively push D1, but do your own work there.
Like M2H and you would make some sense as Partners. Not my top two choices for the Scum Team but if I put my tinfoil hat on this is where I arrive at.
Tbh I still think tommy might be scum (you’re not really clear either tbh), but I think we just have to kill on the dusk wagon today cause I see no way you and tommy are both scum but it’s possible both scum were on dusk.
Make sense?
Yeah I don’t disagree… Tn was still pinging me more heavily D1 so I’ll just get back there but StarV is frustrating the crap out of me.
VOTE: Tn5421
Hard disagree on this making any sense from me as Scum but I don’t think anyone gets to claim that they’ve been cleared so that’s fine.