False. I lynched you because you freaked out and stopped participating and claimed not cop like Josh said.
I told you that I thought you were town
Yeah but mafia is a team game, so I think it is townâs fault as a whole that lead to their loss. I do understand that erikaâs play was exceptionally bad so maybe you could argue it is unfair to town. But as a team scum outplayed town and were on track to win because of this (i.e. we didnât gamethrow). So that is why I feel it is a bit unfair that our victory was kind of taken away.
You didnât outplay us though. You are just trying to capitalize on Erika doing something which was essentially her playing against town and for scum
But I was the cop
Yeah but that was very bad play, which we outplayed. I donât think scum had some amazing performance donât get me wrong. But it still outplayed town because one town player made a very bad play. Does this mean 6 other town players played better than scum? Maybe. But again mafia is judged on a team performance as a whole, not one player.
Itâs not a bad play, itâs a game breaking play.
I am not sure there is a clear line there tbh, playing exceptionally bad isnât technically against the rules, it is just really sucky. I wouldâve liked to have gone with the null for town, win for scum tbh but I guess elli didnât want that anyways. I still think scum team played to their wincon entire way and a town player throwing isnât the blame of scum so their win shouldnât be compromised, no matter how horrific that play is because part of scum play is preying on the weakness of town.
Hard disagree and the difference here is between game throwing and game breaking. Game throwing is playing badly but still attempting to win, just playing in a way that negatively effects your game.
Game breaking - which is what erika did here - is forcing the game into a situation where your team can not recover because of your actions, regardless of what they do. Like because of her we were always going to have to lynch two straight Town there regardless of what happened because she played for scum there.
I think realistically is what wouldâve happened is erika would eventually unclaim and get lynched, because she wasnât gonna let mewtwo get lynched I hope. So mewtwo gets nightkilled and town has you (ds) as conftown in 5 person lylo. So it wasnât completely lost for town, just a lot worse than it was.
So, no, she wasnât doing that per her own admission.
huh wtf
Yeah, hence- gamebreaking for town.
So, DS and M2H were witnessing a robbery, so they decided to burn down the store in order to stop the thief.
No one is in the right here.