Argh, I agree with you. I wouldn’t want to help setting this precedent.
Honestly, I’ve mostly been copy/pasting posts used in other games recently to see what happens . So it’s funny that people are like…
“Oh, this is StarV town game”
Or
“StarV doesn’t do this as town”
When I copied it out of a game where I flipped opposite.
I am fine with this counting as a Scum win.
yeah game should def be a scum win imo, at the very least DS & m2h should get an L for forcing the mods to abort the game.
No one’s getting a W or a L - I’m not doing a Flash vs. Jaedong power outage call. If you strongly disagree with this message me.
r.e. Role PM’s:
Both DS and M2H have gave me their word it won’t happen again. I consider that enough for the issue to be closed. If ANYONE who reads this doesn’t get why that’s something you should never do please message me over whatever medium and we can talk about it.
For all the other potential issues that popped up - I may not have time to address til tomorrow.
Eh, but Jaedong was at a significant advantage, to not make the call would have been bad.
My first scum game and this bs happens. Everyone go kiss themselves
Hey… I guess you can summarize this game by saying DS is scum.
We did have him though, you just had a meltdown
yeah game should def be a scum win imo, at the very least DS & m2h should get an L for forcing the mods to abort the game.
Eh, we 100% lynch dusk day 2 if Erika doesn’t throw so I disagree
Yeah I know I said that I think the game was still uncompromised until two town players posted their role pms. I would feel kinda robbed if I didn’t get a win here tbh because I think I could’ve probably mislynched both mewtwo and erika (in whatever order) after that fiasco. Not saying that there is any merit to being able to do that, be cause obviously the game was thrown. But scum had a very clear path to victory before town posted role pms.
See and that’s kinda the point. What Erika did was gamebreaking for town because it forces us to lynch between DS/Erika/Mewtwo and then to lynch the opposing side the next day basically guaranteeing a scum victory.
I agree with a lot of what you just said, I think you misread my point. I do think erika gamethrew. It should only be ccing done by scum yes. However, that is not what happened, and if a town player misplayed, then that is not scums fault and imo is not a reason to abort the game. Scum would’ve won because erika threw, I am not saying we were in a good spot prior to the cop cc.
See dusk, the thing is, just as you are saying that it is not scums fault that someone misplayed, it is also not towns fault that Erika chose to play against her win condition and break the game like that
I disagree, I said I wasn’t going to comment on something that was outside of the thread and the cop along with others piled on.
At that point, if I’m not willing to comment, I’m dead, so it didn’t really matter what I did after that.
Especially with Josh in the game too, I’m usually dead day 1 regardless of anything that happens.
I disagree, I said I wasn’t going to comment on something that was outside of the thread and the cop along with others piled on.
The thing was, the entire end of day I think I asked one question on that and then dropped it so that outside the thread thing had no impact on why I lynched you.
Nah, you lynched me because you would lynch just about anything that moves.
Clearly it’s the votes that came before that were terrible (Josh, M2H… Was there any other town on my wagon at that point?)
Yeah, it’s really just Josh and M2H.