MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

[Firekitten]

@deadbananas

To the people voting GKB is it just to try to get him to post more like Jake or do you actually get a scum feel?

@deadbananas

Cause reading through GKB 's posts I dont see anything that jumps as scum to me, but he isnt really being helpful to the town or active either.

@deadbananas

This is probable the worst post. GKB wasn’t the top wagon and has less posts than andre, also feels OMGUS af.

@deadbananas

@GoalkeeperBoss

Look at this try hard trying to solve the game

Bad start for GKB since he is responing to a legit question about the game, but it was within approx 30 minutes of the game started so can be taken as a joke.

@GoalkeeperBoss

I’m tryna read the room rn, it’s a good thing I’m illiterate cuz there is nothing to read here

Joking attitude and dismissive of developments in the thread, not sure of this comes from a scum place or a disinterested townie though.

@GoalkeeperBoss

That’s a bold move hopping in halfway through day 1 and just jumping on the top wagon. I wanna hear more from you
VOTE: Andresvmb

This is probable the worst post. GKB wasn’t the top wagon and has less posts than andre, also feels OMGUS af.

would be amazing if these two were scum together

[Firekitten]

@deadbananas

I think you misunderstood my post. I was going over the posts I saw most people voting GKB referencing and that jumped out the most. There were 3 posts I saw for that so I wanted to give my own analysis on them. The first two my analysis was they can come from either side so you guys would say they are NAI. My analysis on the third post is that this one most often comes from a place of scum therefore the scumlean. I apologize for not taking the posts the exact same way you did and seeing some ambiguity in things.

disregard my last post

[Firekitten]

@arete so what do you think of the goalkeeper wagon right now compared to the person you are voting.

[clonedcheese]

@Seththeking

You would rather Arete lynched over GKB?

I’d rather orange than GKB.

I don’t like people going onto wagons because they think they can’t do anything

@orangeandblack5

Voting today is kinda meaningless ngl

agreed

[Srceenplay]

@clonedcheese

maybe he’s just trolling? It’s day 1…

Maybe if they are going into the end of the day as the top wagon they will do something to change people’s thoughts.

[Firekitten]

@GoalkeeperBoss

I’m just very used to being a top wagon d1 and it’s very frustrating to try and defend myself on the basis of nothing

Here’s some helpful advice:Ignore it, especially if we aren’t near end of the day.

Right now you are in a weird spot. You started this game off with a joke, while disappearing after every post. You come out to the thread every now and then to post about something that isn’t useful to advance the game state, or you do give a vote but since there’s like no other substance in your posts people perceive that vote as scummy.

If you are town it’s a really simple idea, just be more on topic if you don’t have a lot of time on your hands to post in the thread. Interact with the people who are accusing you. It’s really not that hard of a concept.

[orangeandblack5]

But like

We always lynch redflymptacc today

[Firekitten]

Is his name just going to constantly mutate every time you say it

[clonedcheese]

wasn’t there talk about leaving GTacc to night actions

[orangeandblack5]

That’s dumb

The whole point of the miller claim is to not get checked

[orangeandblack5]

tbh it’s better to always lynch D1 miller claims

[clonedcheese]

I agree
but…
eh

[ErikaFurudo (Hustlevania)]

@GoalkeeperBoss

That’s a bold move hopping in halfway through day 1 and just jumping on the top wagon. I wanna hear more from you
VOTE: Andresvmb

so you only pop in when ur voted?

[ErikaFurudo (Hustlevania)]

it’s better to lynch neutral claims or scum xd

[orangeandblack5]

@ErikaFurudo

it’s better to lynch neutral claims or scum xd

First off

Sure on neuts but none will

Secondly

Miller claims are >>>rand scum

[Srceenplay]

How many first post miller claims are scum?
I think I have seen it once.

[clonedcheese]

millers claims are usually scummy I think in normal games
But this is rolemadness
and PMFM had the most powerful town role be a miller to balance so
I don’t think the miller claim is the most necessary lynch rn.
A candidate, sure, but only after we explore all other possibilities
mainly I want to see GTacc come onto the thread and talk more before we make any decisions

Orange, on the other hand…

[Marshal]

@clonedcheese

@Marshal @orangeandblack5 please explain.

arete’s point is true and why i wanted to vote jake

and i think orange voted first and i like sheeping wagons and giving them momentum because it’s fun and gives good analysis

so it all lined up

[Marshal]

well i just saw a game with a first post miller scum claim lmfao

[Arete]

@Firekitten

@arete so what do you think of the goalkeeper wagon right now compared to the person you are voting.

it’s fine? I think Bananas has higher scum equity at the moment which is why I’m voting there but it’s not, like, obviously terrible