MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@orangeandblack5

Gues it was Rika

I don’t think I agree with them

But I’m also not sure how much I wanna dig through the LHF like you suggest

Are you talking about this?

@ErikaFurudo

I’d just feel awful if im getting wolfed on by all of you higher posters without even trying to hang em

[deadbananas]

I don’t think scum could of predicted the mod kill. I think their origional plan was to let one of us be shot, Jake kinda volunteered for that and then when me or jake flipped town you guys would lynch the other one. When jake was modkilled the plan changed, because now if they let doggo shoot me you guys know your top two scum bois are dead and both town letting town re-evaluate for the lynch. By killing doggo who doesn’t give you guys info about scum really they make sure they can assert their dominance by killing the big threat to them tonight and letting it snowball on.

[deadbananas]

@Andresvmb

I get it - from your POV you’re going to argue that you’re Town and phrase things from that perspective. But the Scum decided it made sense to eliminate Doggo only after Jake was Mod Killed (and not before), which means that if the choice really was between two Town, why not just let Doggo shoot then? That’s definitely best case scenario no?

TLDR
no, because of info, scum need to control the game not just kill town

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@orangeandblack5

But I’m also not sure how much I wanna dig through the LHF like you suggest

Can you clarify who you think is LHF? I think you should also put forth a POE of your own.

[Seththeking (TrueSoulEnergy)]

@Seththeking

@deadbananas

all im saying is we are falling into the trap set by the scum, I know Im town so my reasoning is from that standpoint.

Ok.
Then who do you think is the scum that set this trap?

Answer this Banana or Hardclaim Scum.
Please and TY.

[Srceenplay]

@Arete

so Jake has, for a while, had a problem where he often, when getting pushed as wolf, devolves into toxicity-and-adjacent things (like, to put things into perspective, he got banned midgame on my homesite, twice, for instances of this)

I was reading him as likely town based on the fact that he wasn’t doing that this game

however, in trying to decide between him and Marshal, I thought it was more likely that Jake had figured out ‘don’t be toxic if people are pushing you as scum’ than that Marshal was scum

would you describe his end here as toxic?

[deadbananas]

@Seththeking

Ok.
Then who do you think is the scum that set this trap?

Im thinking that there is atleast one deep wolf and atleast one wolf in an inactive
My PoE for that is Arete, EricKline, Snowman, GKB, and SrceenPlay. Maybe Litten.

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I am very much of the mindset when I play Scum to eliminate immediate and obvious threats above all else. I think this counts as such. Controlling the flow of the game is all great, but it’s better to survive like a cockroach and have the Town implode. Much easier.

[orangeandblack5]

hot take

If Mist is subbing in it’s to a scum slot

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@deadbananas

I don’t think scum could of predicted the mod kill.

Note that I didn’t say this. What I said was that the Scum only really acted following the Mod Kill. Which makes sense right? If Doggo, Town, really was likely to shoot Jake, also Town, then why not just let it happen?

[orangeandblack5]

@Andresvmb

Can you clarify who you think is LHF? I think you should also put forth a POE of your own.

I want to sort out where Arete/Srceen are before I finalize a list for today

[orangeandblack5]

I think dead’s point is that if they do, the lynch hits scum

[orangeandblack5]

That being said I’m happy to give thoughts on any particular slot

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Are you sure about this? Because remember, Jake had a red check on Doggo. If Doggo actually shoots, and kills Jake, how do you know that the lynch doesn’t end on Doggo?

I’ll quote Arete here:

@Arete

So are we going to talk about how Jake was probably town and probably has a redcheck on Doggo

Because that’s a thing

[deadbananas]

@Andresvmb

If Doggo, Town, really was likely to shoot Jake, also Town, then why not just let it happen?

Thats exactly what I am saying. They were going to let it happen then lynch me because me and Jake were the two main targets so when one of us flipped town the other would then be the target for the lynch. The modkill changed this becuase then if they let doggo shoot me you guys would have two town to give you more info to make your lynch before scum could get their night shenanigans off. By killing Doggo they predicted your logic of just let it happen and are using it to control the information and the power of the game.

[orangeandblack5]

@Andresvmb

Are you sure about this? Because remember, Jake had a red check on Doggo. If Doggo actually shoots, and kills Jake, how do you know that the lynch doesn’t end on Doggo?

Are you kidding me

In what world was Doggo ever scum after today

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I think we just view the calculation by Scum differently and it’s obvious as to why since I am concluding that you are Scum for it and you will obviously disagree. This is not going to end anywhere productive necessarily, so I’ll let others also talk.

[orangeandblack5]

“I am the law” was a play so good that I’d honestly have let scum!Doggo win before I touched him

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Did I say that that’s what I thought? I am saying that you don’t know what would have happened if Doggo actually shoots Jake.

[orangeandblack5]

I think it was pretty clear that nobody ever actually believed the red onnDoggo