MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

[Seththeking (TrueSoulEnergy)]

@Srceenplay

Its sucks that dog died. It would be really helpful to get a chance to do things twice

Why continue to mention this?

[Srceenplay]

we wont have a chance to lynch like that again.
With the amount of town died and the size of the game it doesnt look good. Need a miracle.

[Srceenplay]

because it sucks i and want you to know it

[Srceenplay]

I’m working but hop in from time to time.
Bounce things off of me if you need to.
I probably wont have the greatest answers but I’ll be honest. Thats the best way I know to show I’m town.

[bepwei]

DeadBananas (3): Seththeking, Arete, Andresvmb

Not Voting (9): Srceenplay, orangeandblack5, EricKline, snowmaninblack, darth_tabor, deadbananas, GoalkeeperBoss, ErikaFurudo, Firekitten

Now searching for a replacement for snowman

[orangeandblack5]

@Arete

[Arete]

@Srceenplay

But back up cop didn’t die?

In the game this is based on there was a claimvig but they could only shoot once per day

also I don’t trust the backup cop

[Arete]

@Arete

@Arete

…on-voters/people voting off wagon, which of unflipped people would be Eric/Seth/Snowman/GKB

admittedly part of this is that I TR 3/5 people on the Marshal wagon and think a fourth vote is likely to come from town
I’m starting to worry that I’ve miscleared someone, like, at this point my immediate PoE is {Screenplay, Bananas, Seth, snowman, GKB} with Eric and Darth as sort of existing vaguely near that general PoE and that just feels too easy? and actually now that I think about it Litten is claiming a mech clear on Seth which would make my PoE {Screenplay, Bananas, snowman, GKB} plus sorta Eric and Darth and that really feels too easy, like, that’s a 4-person PoE and there are probably 4 scum
this was supposed to be a VCA post and it turned into rambling thoughts on the gamestate but Oh Well

Dog flips and you paint him green. That’s a “us” VS everyone else mentality.

…why would I not make him green??

[Arete]

@orangeandblack5

How much do you wanna bet this killed the user

he didn’t post ‘/DIE playername’ so probably 0

[Arete]

@orangeandblack5

@Arete

Jake being a villager arguably makes Srceenplay’s EoD marginally less terrible?

Weren’t you the one telling me it looked awful regardless of Jake’s alignment when I brought that up?

It looks bad either way but it looks slightly less bad now

‘less terrible’ doesn’t mean ‘not terrible’

[Arete]

the heck is up with your site meta that people are suggesting ‘SK that shoots during the day’ and ‘the public probable-dayvig was redirected to themself despite never using their ability’ as more likely than ‘a claimvig exists’

[Arete]

@orangeandblack5

But unless we assume that Osie modkilled a town for pasting in a part of their role card, which seems incredibly unlikely, then that just didn’t happen

I’m assuming this post has a typo?

[Arete]

@orangeandblack5

@Arete

[Arete]

@Srceenplay

I’m working but hop in from time to time.
Bounce things off of me if you need to.
I probably wont have the greatest answers but I’ll be honest. Thats the best way I know to show I’m town.

Can you re-read EoD with the assumption that wagons are TvT and give me your thoughts on what sticks out to you?

also @orangeandblack5 since you just pinged me can you post something, IIRC M451 has an 8-in-a-row limit

[Srceenplay]

sure

[Arete]

@Arete

give me your thoughts on what sticks out to you?

Like specifically, who seems disconnected/content/not really caring about the wagons, that’s the main thing I’m looking for right now

but if you notice anything else I’m happy to hear your thoughts

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@Srceenplay

we wont have a chance to lynch like that again.
With the amount of town died and the size of the game it doesnt look good. Need a miracle.

It’s not that dire. We probably have two (?) more mislynches I would think? Assuming two deaths tonight and a Town mislynch, and the fact that we probably don’t have 5 Scum, we probably don’t lose today right away. I think the pool is fairly narrow right around now anyway, so we have a decent chance to hit.

I also want to maximize information, and lynching Eric just doesn’t do it for me. It probably doesn’t substantially change the direction of the game.

[orangeandblack5]

@Andresvmb

probably don’t have 5 Scum

I would agree but the possibility of an NK being thrown about scares me a lil bit on this point

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Having said that, if my initial gut read on Eric was right, I’ll take some pride in that haha

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

@Arete

It looks bad either way but it looks slightly less bad now

‘less terrible’ doesn’t mean ‘not terrible’

You know, I really do think Srceen is just Town. I have been consistently saying it, and I still maintain it. He’s not playing like how I’ve seen him play Scum, and unless he’s drastically changed his style over a few games (which could be throwing me off), I really don’t think we need to worry too much about him yet. I think there’s other players that are far more suspicious for sure.