MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

Completed Games Completed Onsite
#2402

???

1 Like
#2403

granted I suck at mechanics so maybe theres a role im missing IDK but i fully believe in Occams razor

#2404

@Arete
So you believe that Scum has a Day Vigilante?

#2405

How is that relevant? Iā€™m asking if Arete thinks Doggo is scum. How does me being more likely scum say anything about whether Arete thinks Doggo is scum?

#2406

When they claimed I tried looking for this but gave up

#2407

it doesnā€™t im just putting my opinion in, next time I wont interfere with a question you ask

#2408

wow the thread hasnā€™t been dead

will catch up soonā„¢

#2409

Your Welcome!

#2410

The simplest solution isnā€™t always the right solution.

If I told you that the square root of 5743 was 100, it would be a simple answer but a far cry from being the right one.

#2411

I was literally saying that scum!Jake was more likely but Iā€™m not going to rule out a scum dayvig

Iā€™ve been in games with scum dayvigs before and so has Rem

#2412

orange you missed the rollercoaster

#2413

it definitely isnt always, but more often than not it is

#2414

simple solution doesnā€™t equal random by the way

#2415

it also means logical

1 Like
#2416

But you think Mafia Day Vigilante has a higher chance of being rolled then that of Framer?

#2417

Last game I was in im pretty sure had a day vig.

#2418

a scum day vig

#2419

I think he just gave a bad example Tbh.

2 Likes
#2420

p(framer exists) =/= p(Doggo is town and framed)

or in English, there being a framer wouldnā€™t necessarily mean Doggo is town and framed, like, if youā€™re going to try to solve it with math you also have to factor in the probability that they targeted Doggo

1 Like
#2421

yeah thatā€™s why heā€™s not a lawyer

2 Likes