MHA Mafia Game Thread - Game Over

I feel like you’ve really only mentioned one other player though?

alright

can you explain this meta-read to me like I have no familiarity with his meta

1 Like

Also when is your yet

@Arete convince me you’re town and don’t you dare pull another FM2

I don’t think I could fake my EoD yesterday (specifically the part where we thought Gtacc was a suicide bomber) if I had TMI that Gtacc’s claim was real

also like

there’s no world in which scum!Arete is more-or-less given free reign to arbitrarily declare one of V!Marshal and V!Jake scummier, having expressed townreads on both of them, and I push for Jake to be the lynch, like, you have ever seen Marshal play, and this game is a fairly central example of Jake’s play, and I’m familiar with both of their play

I said this in a game where he was Scum (and I called it correctly):

He could have changed it up, sure. And this happened fairly recently, so take it with a grain of salt. But it probably still applies to some extent - Srceen is just visibly more transparent as Town.

I don’t think this is quite accurate, but I understand that I’m a bit tunnely at the moment.

If deadbananas flips Town, then feel free to push anyone you feel like. I don’t know what I’m going to do if that’s the case.

@Andresvmb

assuming for the moment that Srceen is town, who do you see as the most likely misclear candidates?

not sure what this means

Let me break it completely down, and see where I come out.

Town
{Doggoplays, JaketheWolfie [assumed], GTacc, clonedcheese, Marshal}
Strong Lean Town
{ErikaFurudo, darth_tabor, SeththeKing}
Lean Town
{Srceenplay, FireKitten}
Slight Lean Town
{Arete, Orangeandblack5}
No Read
{snowmaninblack}
Lean Scum
{EricKline}
Strong Lean Scum
{deadbananas}
Third Party?
{ }

I am amazed snowman is still in the game and hasn’t been Mod Killed, but at the same time if they are Town, and they are Mod Killed, then we are royally screwed.

I’ll also say why I don’t have a stronger Lean on you - I think you’re perfectly capable, given how you’ve played this game, to pull exactly this off as Scum. Not incriminate yourself, stay outside Town wagons, don’t make any obvious blunders. You’re calculated and controlled and it’s always tough to fully trust such players when they haven’t lead the way to a Scum lynch.

If we have miscleared anyone btw, it’s probably FireKitten. They did claim a mechanical clear on Seth, so it’s highly unlikely that Seth and FireKitten are both Scum. But FireKitten could still be Scum. I don’t necessarily see it, but it’s a possibility.

Now, I really want to flip deadbananas. I think it’s a must. I think if we don’t do it, we’re guaranteed to lose. There’s just too much that points that way.

1 Like

My POE then, to make it more obvious, is everyone from Slight Lean Town down, and you already know in what order I would lynch folks.

Wow our top is significantly more different than I had assumed

Thats the interactions that stand out to me and I think it makes orange look the worse.

I mean you can tell me how you disagree and why. I think now’s the time to be putting things out there.

Obviously I’m going to

Just need to go pick up some food and I can spitball while I eat

Also this was all because of Overwatch FM

I was having severe PTSD

so Jake has, for a while, had a problem where he often, when getting pushed as wolf, devolves into toxicity-and-adjacent things (like, to put things into perspective, he got banned midgame on my homesite, twice, for instances of this)

I was reading him as likely town based on the fact that he wasn’t doing that this game

however, in trying to decide between him and Marshal, I thought it was more likely that Jake had figured out ‘don’t be toxic if people are pushing you as scum’ than that Marshal was scum

you left out GKB – where are you at on them?