That’s always part of it, but I hardly have reads on anyone, so no.
At first I was a little bit concerned with how Eric assumed that both the wagons were bad; I thought he was using TMI when he was posting how they were bad but he only skimmed through them. However afterwards he looked through Dead’s posts and concluded that he’s scummy, which gives me the feeling that he’s actually trying to scumhunt, and you know, not using TMI to fuel his decisions.
2 Likes
Whats tmi
I get where you’re coming at with the post restrictions, however, he has mentioned his post restrictions and I don’t recall any character speaking in poems, so I don’t see a motive for the mods to include it flavor wise
too much information
it’s what wolves have
1 Like
Overall it just seems like a novel way to not contribute and get ignored in meta and in general
1 Like
Votecount as of post #1405
DeadBananas (4): Arete, Marshal, GTacc, Firekitten
GoalkeeperBoss (3): deadbananas, Srceenplay, Seththeking
GTacc (2): orangeandblack5, GoalkeeperBoss
marshal (2): darth_tabor, ErikaFurudo
Firekitten (1): DoggoPlays
orangeandblack5 (1): clonedcheese
Clonedcheese (1): Andresvmb
Not Voting (3): EricKline, snowmaninblack, JakeTheWolfie
Hit the little hammer button to the left of reply to get a VC as of any post.
1 Like
Okay, so time to bring in a bit of a duble standard
Both goalkeeper and dead bananas have been pretty equally useless as of yet (well let’s say efficient…orange is correct with the observation that dead does seem to be putting in effort)
However, I know gkb a lot better
I’m gonna have to give a town read as of yet for him.
His failure to be productive clearly comes more from a joking standpoint and a lack of caring then making bad moves on purpose. Plus, this activity is very in line with gkb strat. I don’t know that it’s necessarily bad, it is drawing reads and reactions. His scum games are much more planned and executed. Town games, at least for d1-2 are BUILT on these short snipts of arguments. The joking never goes away, but the usefulness will increase.
So, town read gkb
Scum dead.
I have class for an hour and a half
See y’all at T-1 I guess
Okay I’m going go be a productive human and I’ll.be back hopefully with a somewhat reasonable amount of time left before EOD
Lol imagine having class during the pandemic
VOTE: marshal
That post is not what I voted GKB for, that was before I did my actual analysis of his posts. On the whole topic of GKB im going to leave him out of my list but give him some attention up here. Alright so first off looking through his posts I was getting a jovial look of not really caring about the game. Then I read through him again and his OMGUS post put him as top scum target for me. Thats changed now that he’s claimed backup Alignment cop. His old posts which i read as useless and jovial now make more sense in the eyes of hey Im basically vanilla town until my guy dies but also Im an important role so while I can’t really do much I should stay out of a target from scum. Obviously he did too good of a job at it. The OMGUS still doesn’t sit well with me but the rest of the post now makes more sense if I put myself in a mindset of GKB being anxious about dying because cop is important but powerless as of now. UNVOTE
For a reads lists I’m going to leave out everyone whose null for me
Reads list
Town read:
Townlean:
andre- Biggest town vibe from this slot and mind melded a few times with it
Orange- too many posts to go through but overall their playstyle is very towny and they have been the biggest scum hunter even if they have been rather unhelpful at times
Erika- posts feel jovial in a way I don’t think comes from scum but I’ve never played with them before. They seem to be like the most reasonable player not jumping on people they could easily jump on and get away with.
Seth- this slot just feels towny and innocent, however some of their play has been rather confusing but that appears as if it comes from town as well.
Litten- Has had some really good posts and is clearly trying to scum hunt
arete- While arete has been misinterpreting like all my posts and then ignoring the clarification, I think their interaction with other people remind me more of town arete.
Nullscum:
Marshall - pops in and doesn’t really do any actual scum hunting or participating in a major way, so far two of his three votes have literally been no explanation and the last one his only explanation was he is sheeping arete.
Scumlean:
Gtacc- I mean I’m not sure if this is the right place to put a policy but here he goes
cheese - while him focusing on orange doesn’t fit with my earlier theory it still feels odd and not like town cheese. His progression just seems all off and he keeps on diverting people and splitting wagons.
With all that said I feel the best vote right now is for Gtacc. I’ve never played with a miller but from seeing what other players I know our experienced and good have said, looking it up, and using basic reasoning they are the best lynch here. VOTE: Gtacc
The thought I had was that it was Bananas’ fakeclaim in PMMM so if anyone on the scumteam was around for D2 of it they’d be familiar with the concept.
Where has he made strong moves this game
Gtacc is a Miller claim
How would that help
1 Like
trying not to fall back asleep
currently Bananas
might change it once I read up
Iirc I did not play that game
I probably missed something but what’s with marshal votes?
Has bananas played in multiple games as town? I only remember FM1/2, and from what you’re saying I assume they were mafia in PMMM. Is there another game I’m missing?