Marked for Death (1,1) - OVER

[Josh]

scummy post

pushed town forward congrats

[Ellibereth (Elli)]

Votecount as of post #1063

DS (2): chesskid3, ChadMD
Josh (2): DS, Andresvmb
ChadMD (1): Urist

Not Voting (2): tn5421, Josh

[Josh]

hey @ChadMD DS and I pretty clearly srent partners stop fosing both of us

[chesskid3]

I think the Andre’s in that game is fairly different from the one here i agree with you

But that was also like May 2018? Like im not seeing the overconfidence that you are here.

Help me lynch DS, Josh, and get mad at me if you want but I cant read the anger from you

[chesskid3]

I fell asleep I’m sorry

[Josh]

I want to see what tn thinks. it’s his choice if we do ds or not.

[chesskid3]

@tn5421 5th time’s the charm lol?

[Josh]

DS was who star had as top scum read, right?

[chesskid3]

I think u and then DS were his top 2? But then there were like 3 other people too by the end iirc

[Josh]

he also said I wasnt his top scum read but I was the best lynch, but i dont think he actually said who he was scum eeading

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

DS was who star had as top scum read, right?

Lol not even close let me find it

[chesskid3]

Uhhh it is definitely close seeing as he changed his read ON Chad to town just to make it clear he had u as lockscum?

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

So, @tn5421 , @Andresvmb nd @DS I feel like the game is in your hands right now.

Here he is saying his three top town picks

---

Here he says that Josh is blatant scum

My scum read on you since minute one because this isn’t your meta town play and blatant scum slips is hardly forced

---

JOSH IS SCUM GUYS

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

wait so we have arrived at Josh and I are just lockscum because everyone else is town right Star?

I mean you said it yourself yesterday CK

[chesskid3]

Wrong, I think Josh is the best lynch, but not my top scum read. You’re not really on my radar right now. I was mostly trolling you because this game is pointless and I’m getting lynched regardless of what I say

Ugh my brain hurts

But you appear to be right @DS

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

An in-depth reads post by StarV

Summary

Here we go:

My initial scum read:

So to back up this you’re going to softclaim that someone in the middle (me) is scum while not backing it with a vote until someone else commits?

Your read is valid either way, but presenting the “normal scum play” and doing just that seems… Scummy.

Now I think town contradicts themselves a lot, so I’m not holding you to that… But playing against an announced strategy is a whole different matter.

Scum hunting DS & Andres

I actually think Urist was right about a lot of things that game, primarily that I was scum. We discussed post-game. But the lynch of the 4 was pretty bad - should be left to that thread’s post-game though, this is a new start!

To be honest, this is a lot like @DS play from last game, just a different plan… But very keen on not being scum read, not so caring about finding a lynch. I’m leaning scum here.

Idk, @DS seems to have a very wifom style of play, last time he came in with a concrete plan of how not to be detected as scum, this time he has the same thing with different words.

I’ve never actually played with town @DS in fairness.

I’ve got Andres, ChadMD and DS in my preliminary scum bucket.

Introducing Josh read:

So, do we lynch Josh or DS?

Checking in with Chesskid and Urist:

@Urist @chesskid3

It’s important you see this at L-1

Confirming neutrality on DS, Scum Read on Josh from earlier scum hunting.

I’m actually neutral on @DS except for post #80, that one triggers warnings, but mostly because I think Josh is scum.

Justifying Josh:

Your play is very different from what I’ve seen of your town play.

He immediately swapped his vote when it was brought up. Which is odd since he initially thought it was L-1 when he posted.

Still on my primary 2:

VOTE: ChadMD

Stating my dislike of possibly aligning a DS win if I’m wrong, has nothing to do with reads:

My main issue with voting ChadMD is that he can’t be scum with DS, so if he flips town, I’m in a real pickle.

I don’t mind him as a backup to Josh which doesn’t seem to be gaining any traction.

Morally, not vis-a-vis gameplay.

Re-affirming my early reads:

I’ll bite on Urist, cheesekid and DS town for today, goodnight. Interested to see if we get a hammer by the time I wake up tomorrow

Reads in the mid-day DS still town, Chesskid still town, tn and Andres fat question marks:

@DS is not so much a scum read is it is a rather lynch target.

My scum reads had to be pretty broad given that half of the game didn’t post.

My top scum read is Josh, but I will accept a day 1 lynch of any: chadMD, tn, Andres.

I don’t scum read chesskid.

I disagree with your assessment of my relationship with DS in this game. Seems like you’re stirring up shit because chesskid called you on your terrible post.

Reasoning for having chesskid as town, andres as scum later disproved via chesskid claiming he wasn’t thinking the way I thought and a revision of Andres post suggests we’re closer in line than I originally thought.

I feel like this is basically a scum claim, also Josh’s decision to present himself as town rather than scum hunting early is the other driver for my vote there even before this.

The fact that @Urist and @chesskid seem to be reasoning with this a bit while @Andresvmb is not raises serious questions about @Andresvmb for me.

VOTE: Andres

Again incorrect logic which I later correct on andres, tn remains town from the moment he starts posting.

I think tn is probably town, Andres I don’t townread because I think his sheep is too weak for reasoning he has displayed in other games.

[chesskid3]

Yeah but this was #595 and mine was #600something so who even knows man

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

I mean Josh claiming that I was his top scum read when he was literally voting Josh and capslocking that he is scum in thread is just lol

[chesskid3]

What I posted was written by Star to me and about Josh and me.

Where he said he didnt think I was scum and Josh wasnt his top scum read but “best lynch”

[chesskid3]

From what I remember he wasn’t a fan of you and idk that Josh is that far off but now I’m looking and not seeing

But Josh def didnt go back and look so I dont see this as at all scummy from Josh