k, who?
I posted my reasoning clearly in #301. The reason it stayed there is twofold: (i) I thought StarV was the scummiest poster on the day up to when I voted, and (ii) I didnât have time to get back in here, catch up and change my mind. Now, I already said that I donât know that I would have switched my vote. If anything, all of the pressure at the end made Star look even worse. And he kept inviting the hammer which I find really annoying.
i also didnât sleep well, but i worked from home today so i was able to get a nap in this afternoon. i just finished watching season 18 of survivor, so now i actually have time for this game woo
lemme know how mm goes
I agree with this to some extent. I mean, I think the person worst âpositionedâ is probably Josh with the final L-1 vote. But moving in and out of a Town wagon when the momentum seemed to be dying down isnât like a positive signal in my mind.
Wait, is anybody here seriously considering relying on StarVâs reads for a vote? #806 from DS easily demonstrate how truly all over the place Star was. You can literally pick and choose any post from Star to support your view for any one lynch here, with the exception of the practically confirmed Town in TN. Like what?
I know for a fact that at least one scum was on the wagon, but I donât see how it makes sense to specifically look on the wagon for scum. The only people off the wagon were myself and Chad. Saying âletâs start by looking at people on the wagonâ really does not help me even a little.
So youâre ruling out the possibility of there being two Scum on the wagon? So shouldnât you be supportive of lynching outside of the wagon first?
do i actually have to put in work here or can we just agree that chad is most likely scum?
Iâm not surprised by the poisoning only because I felt most people put down a Town Read for TN, who barely attracted a throwaway vote by Josh (which happened before TN had even posted).
I donât know if Josh should or even would act differently as either alignment - the history is not there. Iâm just posing the question - is it better as Scum to come out strong at the beginning of the day for the player that was poisoned? And Iâm talking mostly about #707.
Well you know this. I donât. Iâm just TR you, TN is almost certainly Town, and though I donât have a strong positive lean on Chad, Iâm not SR him because he could have cut the day shorter and lynched Town but didnât. And if you really believe that Scum can get away with that (as you said), then how can you make this argument?
This is a ranked game. Put in the work.
2 Likes
I said that scum can get away with it, but that doesnât mean scum will always do it every game. Itâs still seen as a risky play, and Chad may have thought that since he was already under scrutiny, that it wasnât worth the risk to vote for Star.
1 Like
but moooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooom
this post aged so well lmao
1 Like
Hey Chad, where do you usually play forum mafia? Iâm coming to the realization that my read might be due to a style difference and I want to check out your past games.
wow I know this is an easy post to make and shouldnât be AI
but I LIKE IT BY GOD
Actually itâs more that Chadâs slowroll on the Star wagon despite him calling Star scum and saying that he preferred the lynch for the entire day looks scummy as fuck and I want to make sure it isnât a sitemeta thing.
Chad calling Josh scum for half the day and not voting for him either really really looks like Chad didnât want to start a competing wagon, especially since it was evident that myself and Star would have jumped onto Josh as well. I hesitate to call it distancing without flips, but thatâs what it looks like.
This exchange contains Joshâs first two posts.
???
??
???
what???
if this isnât scum theatre iâll shit my pants
1 Like