Mall Pirate Mafia

[Fatmo]

This sounds insane lol

[AKoofD (AKFD)]

makes for a wild ride

[Key]

@AKoofD

https://www.playdiplomacy.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=306&t=60919

Check this out. I was scum here, and my team lost (I conceded the game because of rl stuff)

Thanks! I don’t think I can iso your posts without an account even with the link, but FS said you totally avoided voting your partners. Here you voted Andres which put him up with Capage as the two frontrunners over DKDK, never relented, then also voted for Capage eventually, so I’m a bit less interesting in eliminating you out of the PoE of 4.

@kimpossible I’m guessing that was your line of thinking?

VOTE: nutella
VOTE: Fatmo
VOTE: ActionDan

[AKoofD (AKFD)]

Right! Scum me would avoid bussing my scum partners and would defend them (well tbf 1 scum was bussing Nanook there (Nanook was scum with me and 1 other person), so I decided to not bus Nanook jic)

[Fatmo]

I forget. Key, have you said specifically why you are voting me? Was it you who said you were sheeping Kim or was that Nutella?

I think people ought to be on record about why they are killing the people they are killing, especially when it’s me lol.

[Key]

I’m sheeping the PoE Elli and Kim came up with and said so at the time, because I trust them on their consensus townies. If there’s only one scum in the game atm, we have to eliminate a townie, so if you’re town and we eliminate you I don’t really mind as long as we also take out scum. That’s why it’s a PoE.

I thought you were more town than not yesterday especially after discussion with FS, but I’m not sure how to read your more desperate attempts to not be in the pool today even though there’s likely going to be a townie there anyway. You sound a little bit all over the place with missing claims which are dominating discussion and all.

[Key]

I thought maybe you were tired or something? It must be late for you.

[UFOFever (Derek)]

It’s not even 11 for him. He’s Pacific time

[UFOFever (Derek)]

Hedontsleepmo

[Fatmo]

@kimpossible

Honestly, I’d be more impressed if you had hard defended him. What I saw was you being pretty wishy-washy, in a way that pretty much fits with what I think you’d do if you’re the third scum watching your two partners go down in a landslide.

Just wanted to clarify my answer to this.

First of all, I’m a little surprised you’d describe me being wishy washy as scummy from me on D1 lol.

And like, we know now that there are either 1 or 2 scum in thread now. And it was clear who was going down yesterday. Why on earth would I make myself stick out like a sore thumb so much on something I knew would make me look either really dumb or really scummy When if I’m scum, I know my team is counting on me to try to make it though today either alone or with only one partner, who could also reasonably be expected to be voted what with how good this crew is at catching scum? Like, I even said I had been busy and only showed up in the thread at all not long before the deadline when things were already set in stone. I don’t go out of my way to do anything, especially what I did, if I’m scum there. I made a post like half an hour ago explaining why I thought it was so important to ask Eli those questions before eod.

[nutella]

Meh fuck it fatmos just town

VOTE: ActionDan
VOTE: Duskfall

Remind me why dusk is cleared again

[Fatmo]

@Key

I’m sheeping the PoE Elli and Kim came up with and said so at the time, because I trust them on their consensus townies. If there’s only one scum in the game atm, we have to eliminate a townie, so if you’re town and we eliminate you I don’t really mind as long as we also take out scum. That’s why it’s a PoE.

I mean, alright. I guess defending myself is useless.

You already have a caught scum in Star. So that means two more scum. I’m guessing we win the game anyway. But this kind of mentality you espouse here makes it pretty hard to be engaged here when it seems like the game is on autopilot. I know you guys have success this way, but it’s sometimes not very fun or engaging.

[chesskid3]

Like his 1st post

[Key]

@Fatmo

@Key

I’m sheeping the PoE Elli and Kim came up with and said so at the time, because I trust them on their consensus townies. If there’s only one scum in the game atm, we have to eliminate a townie, so if you’re town and we eliminate you I don’t really mind as long as we also take out scum. That’s why it’s a PoE.

I mean, alright. I guess defending myself is useless.

You already have a caught scum in Star. So that means two more scum. I’m guessing we win the game anyway. But this kind of mentality you espouse here makes it pretty hard to be engaged here when it seems like the game is on autopilot. I know you guys have success this way, but it’s sometimes not very fun or engaging.

No no, I mean - you can still contribute to making sure that scum is in our set of 2, regardless of whether you get eliminated or not, instead of hyperfocusing on making sure you survive. You might have already said, but what are your thoughts on AKD and nutella?

@nutella I said this in chat but I don’t think he fakes this misunderstanding

Mall Pirate Mafia

If I was mafia I’d remove Elli or chess for the first few days assuming they aren’t both mafia I think? Unless mafia is afraid of having one come in d3 with a lot of info

[nutella]

hmm alright

VOTE: ActionDan

wish we didnt have to kill a townie today lol

[nutella]

wait actually I’m not sure I’m understanding

@Nanook

The scum team will assign between 0 and 4 of their number to the Late Arrival group,

I think I had the same assumption dusk did? That the scum choose which members are late, not just how many? The wording here sounds like that, did we have confirmation otherwise?

[Fatmo]

Plus, making people actually give explanations for their votes when pressed is important. Otherwise any scum can justify killing a townie because enough people say that person should be in the POE. It’s only D2 abc in my experience, lol Poe is never completely right at the start of D2. So when someone in the POE is killed, man don’t you wish you had as much detail as you could get from the people making that vote? Like why one person in the POE over another.

Again, I know I come from a different culture where that’s more important, and I’m still confused about how you guys do things here, but surely that’s still important to some degree?

[Fatmo]

@Key

You might have already said, but what are your thoughts on AKD and nutella?

Yea I said I lean town on both. More on AKFD simply because more meta experience.

[Fatmo]

I assumed they chose how many and specifically who on their team came late.

[Fatmo]

@Nanook

During N0, the Hooligans will select how many of their number to include in the Late Arrivals. The GM will assign the rest. No roles in this game are scum-specific.

Hmm, I guess it technically never says they choose who. Just the number.