Mafia 451 Draft

[Hannahh (Hannah Marie)]

Ugh, honestly the most annoying thing about this game is that roles are almost 0% nai. Solving based on roles is almost impossible, but I’m sort of used to it… So I when I have a crazy thought about solving via getting just the right piece of info claiming, I get excited for a moment before realizing oh dog doodoo that doesn’t actually matter one bit

Ok I’ve seen “nai” enough that it’s important I know what it means. Please help.

[Hannahh (Hannah Marie)]

Other than that Dusk feels like they are manipulating facts to support them.
Kinda what I felt Josh was doing in our last VM game. (I was wrong then but gut don’t fail me now.)

Was Josh town or scum in that game?

[DoggoPlays (Don't Privatize Our Infrastructure)]

not alignment indicative

[DoggoPlays (Don't Privatize Our Infrastructure)]

never thought I’d see the day where I explain some mafia lingo, halp the world is ending @_@

[DoggoPlays (Don't Privatize Our Infrastructure)]

1. I dunno, I feel like the way Key defended makes her seem more townie. It was really in-depth and, while it was full of wifom in places, I think it was a solid defense. I know when Tommy just hinted that I could be scum I got REALLY upset for no real reason, which makes me think Key is probably also town?

2. I’m glad you won’t immediately vote cause I wanted to kill Tommy for trying to ask you to blindly sheep him.

I will probably sheep the smogoons group, just won’t ship any one individual within it.

[Hannahh (Hannah Marie)]

Oh I just assumed they said it because it was. I’m kinda like, waffling on if Tommy is actually town here or not because he’s play so much weirder than I’ve ever seen him play. I feel like he’s a bit quieter when he’s scum but I think I’ve only played one real forum game with him?

[DoggoPlays (Don't Privatize Our Infrastructure)]

I like the waffles that you make, though.

[DoggoPlays (Don't Privatize Our Infrastructure)]

Also, why don’t the post numbers in the upper right corner of each post match the scroll bar’s numbers on the far right?

[Hannahh (Hannah Marie)]

never thought I’d see the day where I explain some mafia lingo, halp the world is ending @_@

oops I thought you meant not alignment indicative was to me asking about josh’s alignment. I’m not dumb I swear!

[Hannahh (Hannah Marie)]

I will probably sheep the smogoons group, just won’t ship any one individual within it.

Oh yeah I was meant to reply to this but uni wifi has be on and off all day zzz. I can see why you’re a bit overwhelmed wrt so many new people, but I also think just staying and playing within the smogoons group is a recipe for disaster.

[DoggoPlays (Don't Privatize Our Infrastructure)]

I don’t mind being a disaster though

[DoggoPlays (Don't Privatize Our Infrastructure)]

Having fun is more important than trying to not be a disaster, for me at least.

[Wisp (Kyle)]

To be fair I always shoot Nanook here if I was a wolf

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

Also, why don’t the post numbers in the upper right corner of each post match the scroll bar’s numbers on the far right?

Bug most likely @Ellibereth

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

To be fair I always shoot Nanook here if I was a wolf

This is kinda random

[Wisp (Kyle)]

Not really I just woke up, and I was reading the new posts, think it was Dusk that said I benefited the most from killing Nanook

Which he’s not wrong, but that’s only because he’s a good town player, not because of any other reason

Also NK analysis is bad

[StarV (NotanAxehole)]

Nanook is a good town player because he killed a good town player yesterday.

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

…e most to gain from him dying are Wisp (who Nanook seems to think he can get a lock on eventually) and Andres (since as I understand the two of them would probably expect form a towncore at some point if they were both town, and Nanook would probably be scum!Andres’s top threat here). He also proposed Srceen and Erika as other vig targets, but since he only had one shot and he didn’t really seem interested in their lynches, I don’t think they’d be crazy worried.
I want Andres to be town but reading through his D1 looks kind of slim on opinions on alignments, even before the gladiate. There’s a few suggestions like the Doggo scumread but overall I had the impression he was usually more solvy than this. @Andresvmb am I wrong here?
I don’t really have strong feelings either way from Wisp’s iso.

I’ll address this in detail later. I’m going to agree with you that I haven’t had the chance to dive deep into the game yet - I think the gladiate and DS’ reaction made me want to avoid this game for a bit to be honest. And it made it really difficult to get information out of other people.

Doggo’s attempt at trying to form a Town core with players he’s played with before screams of Town to me - so I’m reversing my read. Dusk’s tunneling of you is confusing me, since I actually thought Dusk was Scum when the day ended based on your push but now I’m starting to think it’s just Town!Dusk. Which means that Nanook was broadly correct and I need to read through what he said.

I’m not interested in lynching DS or StarV, but I’m still a bit flabbergasted that we collectively agreed to No Lynch.

[Duskfall98]

I’m not interested in lynching DS or StarV, but I’m still a bit flabbergasted that we collectively agreed to No Lynch.

Ngl, I was surprised we pulled it off too

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

Yeah, you’re all welcome for that.