M19 Doc 14 Game Thread - Mafia win!

you need the starts and the ends of the quotes to be on their own lines

Frankly, part of me wants to town-read aelin just because I feel bad for how frustrated they’re getting, tho logically- I consider it NAI. It feels like a thing they’d be frustrated about regardless of alignment.

What I wanted to say- I’ve been there. I DO see effort. I appreciate it even when I don’t talk about it. I just refuse to town-read it.

genuinely- thank you for caring for the game.

I’d say try to enjoy it even with a lower activity tho frankly… I know how addicting caring about something and just going all in can be
Just well…. Tbh idk what I want to say
don’t scum-read my town-reads, I’ll still murder you for that
yeeting low-posters might be a decent way to win tbh :stuck_out_tongue: even if less exciting
grelgsieejystsksvdjeggkensgeuehebrldu I feel stupid, lemme just dip

Ooooooh
Thank you

VOTE: erich
Partially sheeping, also voting among my POE
Let’s see how it goes

This is correct.
Don’t pity-read me, just read me.

Flash no, just straight up no. All this is doing is widening the pool of people to vote. I see no reason as mafia with ten hours left to leave your vote on a teammate, with that state of the vote count when he was active, then not get back to see if it mattered.

I would treat Andres in the same camp as laser (Heavy tend towards town until pointed to otherwise)

I really, really want to vote you for this but I am going to give you the benefit of the doubt on the reads of the confirmed town onto you and say that this is just a very bad read and not a mafia play to get us to widen a shrinking voting pool.

Further to that point, the voting pool for today I feel should consists of the following,
Aelin, clonedcheese, dwai, ejjinami, EricH, gellnick,
Myself (depending on how much you put into squirrel’s reading of the end of day outcome) squirrel2412, and TheFlash.

————————————

And trusting the reads of who is confirmed my new list at this point of the game looks like this,

Aelin - Town read by fire (post 678)

Overall - Slight Town read

Clonedcheese - Town read by fire (post 678)

Overall - Slight Town read

Dwai - still not seeing much sustenance coming out of this slot but the leaving of the self vote on yourself right and to the end leaving you in threat of being the majority is something I do not feel as mafia would have been done.

Overall - strong Town lean

Ejjinami - mainly only directly interacted with Dwai, and aelin directly which is something to note but not directly indicative of anything. The same point stands from when I did this earlier that the push onto arete could have very much been an attempt to look like you are involved without actually doing much

Overall - slight mafia lean

EricH - I do see where the view of the interaction between jkbear and EricH had been artificially generated drama, I am not as sold on this thread and see it more as Eric pinging a CD active which was inactive and Bear not wanting to interact with the game. But in saying that nothing points to them leaning town through what they have said.

Overall - mafia lean

Gellnick - as noted by everyone he has been quiet, there was an explanation given for that which probably points towards neutrality more then anything else regarding activity. That reads list though was absolutely wishywashy on everything (expect for things that cannot be disputed). Falls into the category for me of “I need to have reads but do not want to look attached to anyone”.

Overall - strong mafia lean

Squirrel2412 - I really like their reading of the end of day festivities and his inclusion of my myself into his cleared group (which I do confirm as correct even though that means nothing to everyone) which does the job of shrinking the pool even further which is town’s job not mafia making me trust him for that.

Overall - town lean

TheFlash - as stated above the andres vote is terrible but I do have to put some credit into what orange is saying about him, both these things “balance out” in my read of him.

Overall - neutral

——————————————————
VOTE: gellnick

Sigh
Anyway
@Aelin
I town read the way that orange was chilling D1
I put myself into their shoes and realized why they were probably just town…
Maybe I was incorrect for the exact reasoning they were town now, but the way they played there was extremely townie to me with the way they were trying to influence stuff
if they executed a villager yesterday I would have probably gave them the squint eye though but

Now that I think about it*

Forgot to mention
@orangeandblack can you talk to me about your reads on flash and aelin?

@ejjinami please fix those quotes aaaaaaa

Okay I did it for you

Flash is by no means lock but I liked his D1 in context and if he keeps that up we cool

Aelin is playing in a way I don’t think is going to net many results but is also indicative of genuine effort imo

1 Like

On that note aelin your mistake is assuming that more visible effort is more better

This is way more than enough posts to have a functional, playable, solveable game. You don’t need hundreds from every player to win, and you don’t need to force every player to explain exactly why they said every word they sent either.

Just because somebody isn’t playing to your own unreasonable standards of what effort “should” look like doesn’t mean they aren’t actually trying, and considering you’ve scumread both of the players who have met your own personal bar for effort, that should really be an indicator that your approach isn’t working lol

Ehhhh, is that ai
/shrug tbh

Tbh that is correct
It’s pretty much impossible to solve the game otherwise

Votecount as of post #755

EricH (2): gellnick, ejjinami
Dwai (1): clonedcheese
Andresvmb (1): TheFlash
Squirrel2412 (1): Aelin
gellnick (1): Quin

Not Voting (7): Andresvmb, Dwai, EricH, Firekitten, laserlab, orangeandblack5, Squirrel2412

Bleh, this is such a mess

The only ones I’m ok with there are gellnick and Erich
Cheese, flash, aelin what do you think of those 2?

(Now that I think of it, they’re cross voting…. So there’s likely 1 scum max there)

On a side note, I don’t think they deserve the harsh words either. Their standards are pretty reasonable imo
But yeah

Hey @Quin how willing are you to switch votes?
What do you think about erich/laser/andres?

Mmm, that might be a bad poe
But whatever