M16 Game Thread

[laserlab (William)]

What would you like to hear?

[Squirrel2412 (David E)]

@Squirrel2412

You asking for Orange to reveal what he picked

@EricKline

Let’s me clear, I NEVER DID THAT

Never in my mind did I have an ounce of concern that he would actually tell me.

That would not hold true for most of the rest of the lobby.

@EricKline

Epic

What did you ask for

Regardless of whether or not you thought he would answer, you still asked him to reveal what he picked.

[Ari_2412]

I don’t see the reason for voting for Kaylee. I’ll reread it instead of just skimming through it

[Squirrel2412 (David E)]

Who you think is town, scum, etc would be appreciated.

[EricKline]

@Squirrel2412

Then why ask him if you know he’s not going to respond?

Why do we do anything here? Idk bro you’re making a mountain out of a mole hill

[orangeandblack5]

If I had time I’d go reread Marbleympics Day 1 to see how Kline acted there

I don’t

But you might?

[gellnick (that random guy on discord)]

Goat Count

orangeandblack5 (3): clonedcheese, GoalkeeperBoss, Arete
k.aylee2412 (2): orangeandblack5, EricKline
EricKline (2): Ari_2412, Squirrel2412
GoalkeeperBoss (1): cattypaws_f

Not Voting (9): TheFlash, EricH, laserlab, 000peo, k.aylee2412, GTacc, bepwei, JKBear331, Quin

Also, @cattypaws_f has asked me to let y’all know that she will not be able to log on before EOD.

[EricKline]

@Arete

my actual point was that you were saying it was stupid for people to talk about their role/pick position, while directly and indirectly encouraging people to talk about them

I disagree that that was what I was doing.

@Arete

but it is in fact also anti-town, if a bunch of people are discussing role/pick position it can potentially make it easier for Mafia to PR hunt, and/or lead to people roleclaiming

But did it actually? Where did something I do reveal any useful pr info to scum?

Also, why didn’t you stop this dinner if you were so concerned? Why didn’t anyone?

[Ari_2412]

Could someone explain the reasoning for Kaylee?

[orangeandblack5]

@orangeandblack5

If I had time I’d go reread Marbleympics Day 1 to see how Kline acted there

I don’t

But you might?

https://www.mafiauniverse.com/forums/threads/26404

[orangeandblack5]

Her opener was defensive af and that’s p much continued

gtg now but it’s not great, see gtacc’s reasoning as well

[Ari_2412]

Okay. At some point she said that she’s not read everything closely. I’m willing to give her the benefit of the doubt this time

[Arete]

Again, my biggest concern is not that you were doing it in the first place (I mean, I come from FoL, as far as I can tell people will say pointless claim-y things no matter how much you tell them not to), it’s that you were saying it was dumb for people to reveal their role while simultaneously saying a bunch of role-related things

[EricKline]

@Squirrel2412

Regardless of whether or not you thought he would answer, you still asked him to reveal what he picked.

Ok I guess?

But that was with the running assumption that he did not have a PR? So what did my question matter?

[clonedcheese]

hi
currently at #586

won’t be able to contribute/read (aAaAaAAaAA collegeapps)

vote remains on orange

[Squirrel2412 (David E)]

We at least try to find scum. The issue I have is that you asked a question that it’s either useless (if Orange doesn’t answer) or helping scum (by helping them PR hunt).

[Squirrel2412 (David E)]

Going to take a break from the thread and revisit it later

[orangeandblack5]

@clonedcheese

vote remains on orange

Okay but why

[EricKline]

So the question for you to ask yourself, then is

Would town eric ask a useless question?

Would scum eric ask a question like this to find a pr?

If the answer is yes to both, which one is more likely?

[clonedcheese]

u sus
pocket bad