M16 Game Thread

Something that I noticed as well but I wasn’t going to comment on it until I was done reading through the rest of the person’s posts (not Cat posts)

Actually tuck reading the rest of these posts

Gonna be looking at bepwei’s posts after he was ‘outed scum’

Ping me if needed

As I said already, that’s what it seems like, hence I asked for a reads list.
I was not repeating EK, I said that plenty earlier and I can send you a picture of my homework load if you’re doubting I’m tired. I was up till 5am last night

I’m not going to do a formal read list, I’m just going to give my thoughts on each player individually as if you thought my posts were confusing already then a very long post is going to be a disaster to read

3 Likes

that’s why I asked for a simple list

No need for that. I beleive that you are tired…but I still find you a little sus.

Twtbw

It’s not extraordinarily out of character? No?

Fair, there are very few people I’m not sus of rn. So idk…I’m tempted to say out arete and see if the mafia has their plan fall apart after that because I have no idea who the other two are and with any luck if they are inexperienced the plan could fall apart after that

@Firekitten @brandn03 what are your thoughts on this post? (May want to jump back to see the others leading up to it)

Looks like he was derpclearing* her because she didnt know that Arete had rechecked him.

*not sure if this is the correct usage of this word. I just learned it yesterday.

Dead at the end of day 1 (I had other things to spend 5+ hours on) if you want them I could post them but it is a seven page document that probably has nothing useful in it. I personally have not looked at it in a couple days.

Should we hammer tonight?
  • Yes
  • No

0 voters

Annoying it’s not showing who voted what

I am going back to this because of where we stand in our claim situation because we have VT claims from everyone (who claims VT) before it was known that the pardoner was maf. So using the outing the pardoner as a maf PR was something that could have very much been discussed pre-game (hence the reiteration of this point by litten) since that pardoner is in that VT early claim bunch.

Ok epic no kill tonight.

I don’t see scum!quin.

Not right now.

Let’s talk about goalkeeper…mmm

The reason I took so long was because I was trying to sort my conflicting thoughts, not because I had a lot to write about. There were several posts by them that I had bookmarked because I viewed them as worrisome, such as #1637 when I initially read them (if you want me to tell you the other posts I thought were worrisome when reading them and the reason for them (even the one I just told you, because I didn’t explain why I find them worrisome) just ask, I’m not going to list them here because I don’t want this post to get too confusing). However, there’s a couple interactions that I cannot read as anything other than town. #786 is the start of the 3 posts interaction that I want to highlight as an example between Orange and Goal. Coupling that post with the context of their earlier posts suspecting Orange, that post reveals a mindset that is very hard to craft as scum believably. Orange noticed this as well, as evident by him responding to that post with #799. Goal one-ups his previous posts by continuing to reveal the same mindset in his post #801. I think it would be insanely hard when faking his mindset to respond to Orange’s post in that manner; Like, you can see him actually rationalizing his push in his mind while wondering if his rationalization makes sense to other people.

In interactions like these keeping the mindset you had in previous posts consistent is difficult for the average scum player, which is why I’m pretty sure he’s just town.

General agreement that brandon and and litten slots are probably the least likely to have been previously investigated?

Conflicting thoughts is a paralysis killer, honestly. Explaining my thoughts shouldn’t have taken that long, but I had to debate whether or not I would weigh his mindset heavily over other stuff.