Josh Mafia - Day 4

Then i suicidebomb somebody else

Suggesting that i suibomb srceen here is strategically bad and doesn’t look good for you star

Well, it’s not bad if you want to see flips on both sides of this fight, which I very much do.

You know what, it would be better if we bombed someone else, let’s say RADicate, then we lynch Srceenplay afterwards.

That would confirm Key’s alignment. A Srceenplay flip confirms nothing.

Lol at the idea of bombing RAF

Is he not in your scum pt?

Except that srceen would have known that his targets would be made public and could have had the rest of the scumteam help him come up with a claim, which he would have had from the start of day 1 to do with the knowledge he would most likely have to claim on day 2. Furthermore, scum!srceen would almost certainly have a role that targets 2 people anyway, because the alternative is that scum decided to get someone who announces their targets to do the scumkill- and that is if whatever target-announcing ability srceen has would work on a factional ability anyways. Finally, scum would be more vigilant of claiming bus driver when scum died in the night and no town did.

However, what was announced was that srceen visited two people, which usually implies a successful action. So I hold that someone is not telling us everything, but most likely because they fail to realise it is important rather than out of malice.

Can we all just agree that the optimal play is for Urist to suicide bomb, demonstrate alignment and then we lynch either Key or Srceenplay depending on flip.

Srceen could also have taken two separate actions, neither of which was the kill.

StarV I don’t know whether Urist is town or scum based on his flavour so no idea why you think his flip would be useful here.

This just makes me think you’re scum which is why I’m calling for the Urist bomb before vote.

UNVOTE

Two separate actions would be far more sensible as fakeclaims go, especially if it was based in reality.

@Urist So, what’s it going to be?

JPG-0005-Joker

Why do you think bus driver is a bad claim for scum? If scum didn’t expect people to be getting explicitly named results, I don’t see why they wouldn’t prepare that.

A srceen scumflip confirms that key and i are town.
A srceen townflip confirms that key is scum and erika is town

It’s very provable

It becomes considerably worse as a claim in light of who died in the night

I disagree.

I’m gonna shoot the moon for a “jj reads role PMs” moment and suggest srceen’s bus driver may only apply to killing actions, but it’s a bit early for theorycrafting when the claims are on the lighter side.

jj should stick to reading the backs of milk bags