who is this StarV?
i chekced and they have the same avatar as urist
maybe thats why i didt even realise they were itg
he has the same avi as Urist
iāll die either way so iāll just give you the finger in that case
Fairly close to what Iāve been thinking tbh
oh I feel slightly less retarded now, phew
agreed
I stayed up a bit later.
But Urist itās been bothering me youāre insisting that Trans gave ice cream to his ice cream partner and killed himself that way.
Like. why. Trans isnāt the sharpest tool in the shed here but surely, surely, it doesnāt take a genius to avoid that.
Itās a little thing I know, but itās seriously engendering a scenario where I can imagine you attempting to throw us off and try to solidify that you were the scum kill (intended or otherwise) and trans was incidental, something that seemed plausible regardless, when in fact you (or erika depending) werenāt shot and lying about your role (again) and trans was actually scum killed.
As for other people
I need to reread fuyu.
key/nsg/star arenāt too memorable, and while I remember more of nsg it wasnāt out of her scum range surely and at this point Iād expect a bit more from her as town.
Chad is still absolutely not town in any universe. You can argue 3rd or scum (or possibly changed alignment to scum if you believe he could change alignment and based on what he said itās reasonble if he insinuated that he would change alignment to town on a scum lynch, heād change to scum on a town lynch)
Screenplay is coming off townier lately.
I would bet Joshās dick that Chad is just a 3p survivor
and if so, knowing that and going after him d2 is dumb imo
Town
{fuyu, DS, Urist, ChadMD, RADicate}
[#263, #382, #789, #820, #958, #978, #1357, #1391], [#130, #1064, #1115, #1321], [#199, #472, #697, #711]
Positive Lean
{Joined_Under_Duress, Texas, ActionDan}
[#304, #601, #622, #713], [#250, #326, #1056], [#608].
Slight Positive Lean
{Danathon, ErikaFurudo, MS}
[#592, #883]
Neutral / Null
{Ellibereth, Key, StarV}
Negative Lean
{Duskfall98, the_worst, Northsidegal, Chesskid3}
[#150, #334, #491, #527, #543], [#222], [#577], [#1448]
Confirmed Scum
{Nanook}
Confirmed Town
{Transcend, Rob, Dannflor}
ā
#750 from Erika is another post thatās making me reconsider. Perhaps I wouldnāt vote there. #856 is just funny. Erikaās comments about Chad D1, and the overall push to not let a claimed BP 3P into D2 are all valid.
Duskās self pity in various posts around #753 I read through quickly and Iām not giving it too much thought because my Negative Lean is already there and they are a bit depressing.
#769 is a bit of the same Iāve been highlighting from Duck already (ālike I donāt townread anything heās doing but I donāt get why the fuck wolf!squirtle is doingā). Itās near constant shading but no real push with bite. I really would like to figure out whatās going on here. But then look at #781. All of those TRās are the same ones I have (with varying degrees of confidence of course), except for the_worst himself. What the hell. And I agree with #818. This one is difficult. Duck constantly going back to Transcend seems meaningful somehow (#967).
@Chesskid3, a lot of your positions have been way off. I am looking at #864 for example. And #867 is strange, since you wrote in #804 that Dannflor should use his Vig Shot exactly how he did. So which is it? Can you also be more useful? You seem to be totally irrelevant which is not how you play Town.
MS pushing Rob is not a great look in #956. Fuyu is on point in #958.
#968 also.
fuyu was on point about the Chad wagon composition in #978, which obviously included Nanook at that point. I will upgrade to a stronger TR.
#985 also gives me bad vibes. TR Chess at that point, and for those reasons, seems poorly thought out. #987 says it all.
Dusk is the first to vote Rob after RADicate comes out with the Guilty, and does not even ask a question about it, even though RADicate had stated that they meant to Cop Dusk. RADicate only later clarified what had happened (in #1004). However, Duskās point on #1019 shows some awareness as to why Rob would not have immediately claimed, which is interesting and not something Scum might have wanted to highlight if they wanted to blindly push for a bad lynch. So Towny points there. But then you get #1045 and #1050, and it goes somewhat out the window. So Scummy points there overall.
ADās push in #1033 is understandable, and I agreed, but now I donāt necessarily like it. Itās with the benefit of hindsight, I admit, but attempting to shut down the conversation around what could have happened (by saying that you lynch first, ask questions later) is not the Towniest mindset.
Scum basically wants to ignore Robās claim and push for that lynch, which is easily justifiable really. DSā unvote in #1115 is a strong indication that DS is Town here. Chessā push in #1111 does not quite have the same opposite effect obviously, since the reading of the literal role is correct, but the incentive is there for Scum to diminish the Claim as a lie. DS even follows later in #1119. Also, if DS is Scum and is really trying to have others rely on this for Towny points, he stays off, does not vote, and looks like a genius.
JUD trying to actually parse the Claim in #1125 is Towny.
Thatās D1 for me.
ā
Erika pointing out the positive points in the Nanook ISO for Srceenplay in #1193 is quick, but aligns with what I have been saying.
Keyās contributions in #1201ā¦ arenāt really contributions. #1237 is a good question though.
#1218 - I canāt be sure that Erika knew Transcend would flip Town, but I agree that itās weird that Erika would focus on that one read, but not the Nanook read for example. I am going to say that this on its own will create suspicion in my head about Erika for quite some time.
#1291, mostly agree with fuyu here, but not about the_worst.
#1321 - DSā calling out the_worst in that way seems Towny to me. I also agree with the point frankly.
#1323 - I strongly disagree with Duskās interpretation of RADicateās role. For someone who blindly followed it when it was convenient, throwing shade in this way just seems Scummy to me. DS why you sheeping this nonsense? #1363 from Erika is exactly how I feel about it.
#1405 - Texasā view of Dusk is throwing me off.
#1424 - This is trash. If Chess was killed this game I canāt say I would care all that much.
ā
I will stop here for now.
So thatās my updated reads list after reading most of D2.
Also, to me we should be lynching Dusk, so Iāll just vote there for now.
VOTE: Duskfall98
1 Like
You are just being terrible. Produce content - I know for a fact that you can.
I agree.
Also MS I am still waiting on you to clearly signal your preferred votes with Hurt: [ ].
Iām not going to be around in like 2 minutes, but I have highlighted some of my concerns with your slot I think. Feel free to comment on anything I have posted, and Iāll answer when I check back. Or not, itās up to you really.
What is the case for Dusk? I donāt really see anything AI.
heās froze, but the whole rad is wolf thing is kinda too brazen 
1 Like
he wolfread two townies and a wolf and pushed only the townies was the point.
Well what do you think about the Transcend kill in regard to that? Like do you think a scum!Dusk kills Trascend there? Why would he shade himself like that?
Well that train of thought was about urist, but I kinda assumed the post andres was referring to.