Josh Mafia - Day 4

[Texas]

I have two guesses but one is depressed and the other would be scum reading me so idk

[Texas]

Ooh that’s a post in dusks scum meta

[Joined_Under_Duress (Cheet/Giga/Jjh)]

The most important takeaway is that dusk is deciding who is town or who is scum on a whim and the questions are doing nothing to get him there.

I don’t think you need to pick at his logic to make that apparent.

[Texas]

Who are the three hydra heads? Think I’ve played with one of you

[Duskfall98]

Can we just take a moment to appreciate the hydra:

1. has said I’ve a good town game
2. has tried to push a lynch in me based on my shitposting, only followed up by me being “bad”
3. then tells everyone to ignore me and eliminate a good town player from the discussion in the process

I wonder what the intent is here

[Texas]

dusk since when do u use bullet points

[Joined_Under_Duress (Cheet/Giga/Jjh)]

I think your towngame is good.
Nothing you’ve said contradicts that point. Lol.

[Duskfall98]

They were auto

[the_worst (Duckling)]

okay at least you’ve got your read on me right

I’m gonna give you some benefit of the doubt. if I should be looking at different stuff which you’ve done, can you point me in the right direction? I don’t townread anything you’ve done so far but all I know about you is that you’re Dusky and you’re an adorable squirtle so I don’t have a good gauge on how to read you accurately.

What have you done that’s town indicative? What have you done that’s AI?

you townread me so you obviously think my case on you is well reasoned at some level (I think that’s something you let me in on at like an unconscious level, sorry if that’s a bit witch doctory). where do you think you’ve posted AI and how do you think I should be checking it and getting town?

[Texas]

This would be a lot of effort to put in if duck were trying to pocket dusk

[Duskfall98]

VOTE: joined under duress

Their read on me feels fake. They say I’m good, then try to scum read me solely on a shit post and because they don’t think I’d be comfortable. This alone is a reach mr fantastic would be proud of, but I understand that sometimes people want to just get a read down and pressure etc early game.

However since then he’s not really followed up much, doesn’t seem like he is trying to actually solve my slot. He calls me bad which is such low level fall back play for someone who has nothing else to say. He’s just trying to shade me and push a lynch rather than read me effectively imo.

@the_worst

What part of this post to you disagree with, because this is the point where I think you started scumreading me?

[the_worst (Duckling)]

re. point 3 I think they’re specifically telling us to back off engaging all the time. ngl I tend to derptunnel hyperaggressively on early scumreads and have a knack for shitting up the thread with Too Many Posts and not enough genuinely readable content

don’t necessarily think they were telling you not to post

I actually think that’s +town for the hydra

[the_worst (Duckling)]

pls respond to the thing I asked you about

I’ll try and dissect this but I’m mobileposting before sleep so if I ragequit I’ll lyk and try again later

[Duskfall98]

They said to back off then several posts later they interact with me again which is weird but I dunno if it’s ai

[Texas]

Is there an iso function

[fuyu]

the little person icon in the post box

[the_worst (Duckling)]

Their read on me feels fake. They say I’m good, then try to scum read me solely on a shit post and because they don’t think I’d be comfortable.

I don’t think they were scumreading you for your shitpost dude I think they were prodding you out of your shitposting to see how you’d react

they then thought your reaction was wolfy (ditto)

let’s be wild for a sec and assume they’re wolves who are setting you up for a mislynch or possibly just prodding you to get the game going. why do you think it’s like… cogdis? for them to approach your slot this way? I appreciate that it’s a silly reason to think you’re lockscum and powerlynch you 5 seconds into d1, but what actually makes you look at their post and go “wolf!”?

[Duskfall98]

What have you done that’s town indicative? What have you done that’s AI?

Anything up to where I first started questioning the hydra want ai. From there you can see me attempt to question them and see the logic behind their scumreads on me. I didn’t just go “lol you scumread me I’m voting you”. What I did was actually give them plenty of time to come up with good reasoning. Because it’s not about who you vote imo, it’s your reasoning behind it which helps determine there is towny motive. They failed to give any reasonable argument saying stuff like " you are bad", they are scumreading me off shitposting in RVs stage and they have still given no other reasoning. This is what is bad about their slot, and this is why my vote is on them.

[Texas]

Duck how do you feel about shiptoasting

[the_worst (Duckling)]

I think I hit the nail on the head with just that post actually

I just don’t get why you think it’s scum indicative. I do, however, see why you think that it’s a weak argument.

Two types of people prey on weak arguments. Town who feel hard done by, and scum who feel that the argument is weak => therefore doesn’t have credibility

oh no I’m talking about chainsaw defence. having flashbacks to my first 3 games ever