Josh Mafia - Day 4

I can make a stronger case with some time, but look back over the last 2 days. Everything he’s argued has hurt us (Town). I wouldn’t be sold by his act today - if I’m Scum, I know that two Scum are almost for sure getting lynched: Elli and AD. So I have a lot of time to build credibility and try and not look so bad. But to me, his vote for NSG and overall pushes make me really unlikely to ever want to see him go far in this game. In fact, it’s almost better to lynch a more controversial choice today than the obvious ones to try and suss out what’s really happening.

Great, you weren’t lying about your Night Action. Just everything else.

I think risking a mislynch is strictly lower equity given we don’t know what roles are still in play for scum.

So we can put Flavor next to Star and see who lines up where for example.

That’s all I wanted to hear, thanks for the acknowledgement

Yeah this is fair.

Granted if Elli/Dan had amazing roles as scum you would have to wonder why they would risk saving chesskid.

2 Likes

I’m town though. I think we should lynch Flavor to demonstrate that his claim is shit

Especially so in the case of AD when he probably could just coast by while Elli is getting lynched 9 times out of 10 the next day anyways.

1 Like

I don’t know how to argue this without being a jerk.
So.
Just infer what my argument here is.

1 Like

Yeah, I think we always lynch flavor at some point this game his claim is way too out there and very intense on the “YOU CANNOT LYNCH ME” because mechanics

He’s claiming that we can’t lynch him because it would be “a mistake because he’s town”, not because of his role, apparently.

Given that he did, in fact, open an egg, knowing that he could full well have died doing so.

Because he’s scum

Yup.

I would lynch me if I were you, but that would be wrong.

So, I think it’s best that we get this flavor stupidity out of the way then lynch elli & ad

This sounds to me like protecting a role in the Scum camp. I say we ignore this completely.

Think if anything Flavor is protecting Dusk’s role.

I will vote either or both out, I don’t really care. tbh, I probably won’t keep up with the next 2000 posts either.

Also while StarV’s early reads/votes were strictly wolfish, I’m not really sure if his play in isolation is particularly wolfy? He felt obvious in parity cop. He’s only really feeling scummy via association here which feels ehh.