It's a Comic Book Death, For Me (GSHM dead thread)

Yeah, teleportation is pretty great one too. Mind control is probably the most broken, yeah, but I have to think at some point that probably gets a bit boring.

I’m excited to see what’ll happen today!

What actions were taken last night?

Literally was just writing those up!

I’m looking forward to seeing what happens today too!

Night actions were:

Mylo
Use TS weakness on Screen, NK Screen (failed), watch Effers (saw nobody visit)

Effers
Shoot Mylo (unsuccessful, Mylo cannot be vigged)

Screenplay
Rolecop Andres (discovered his Phase Shift ability)

Andres
Phase shifted (wasn’t targeted)

I’m thinking… wouldn’t the GTVA be broken in scum’s hands? An extra vig kill for scum… when nightkills are already so scarce… broken!

Depends on what the other scum role was. If the Fly Guy and Speedy are in town hands, that makes it considerably more difficult…plus, NKs are a challenge to get off already, so it basically only gives them one semi-guaranteed kill.

But the GTVA doesn’t need to target a weakness in order to kill, right?

Mylo could actually win this, if he makes it to Mylo!

Just need town to mislynch, and not catch on to him!

GTVA does not need to target a weakness, no. Although perhaps that’s be an interesting wrinkle to add next run!

1 Like

It’s strong if GTVA on scum. Helps to process the first nightkill while not knowing anyone’s roles and weaknesses.

I think you accidentally fucked us over with the amendment in roles. They’re getting to the right answer for the wrong reasons. Failure to be transparent regarding scum having to target a weakness in order to make a nightkill also contributes to this. Hope you can correct this so that Mylo will have a fighting chance.

If they ask how the NK works, I’ll answer. I generally try not to put my hand on yhe scale as a mod—the only reason I pointed out amendments is because that’s how it was supposed to read and how it had been functioning…so it would be grossly unfair to have people expecting NK immunity to be a thing.

Was omitting the fact that everyone has NK immunity part of the plan?

I don’t know about you, but I’ll feel bad for Mylo if he got policy lynched just because of the amendment, and he just coincidentally happens to be Superman, who has to be policy lynched.

He’s going to panic his lungs out, and it isn’t even his fault.

Town figured out the puzzle wrong, but got to the right conclusion. It sucks for Mylo and I’m empathetic…but I’m not gonna tip the scales for that.

Well, then GG.

You didn’t give Mylo a fair game… all that’s necessary was to clarify how the NK for scum works, OR keep mum about the role amendment, since it was a bastard game after all… I don’t agree with the decision but I’m not mad I guess.

RIP Mylo it wasn’t your fault.

Literally all the amendment did was make the game how it was supposed to run to begin with.

I understand it isn’t your fault that town coming to the right conclusion for the wrong reasons isn’t actually your fault; it was unexpected. But there is no way that Mylo can defend himself now. It’s not possible to go ā€œOh, scum no killed because of a secret mechanic that nerfs scum and makes nightkills missing!ā€ Because… well, that’s claiming scum! Only you can do that!

It’s be cool if town is just good this game and caught Mylo for the right reasons, like ffery did, but now Mylo is probably going to be traumatized and I’m worried he might even quit 451!