That’s a scummy vote.
Andres, you called something like this out on day 1. Do you see the parallel?
Was it Andres? I remember Screenplay actually calling out mylo for a vote embedded in a sentence. Maybe Andres did as well.
No, this is the post I’m thinking about. MS voted Andres when other players were talking about voting them.
ah ok.
I think kind of the opposite of Urist. I think MS all but spewed him town.
Absent that, I’d probably have Urist in my top tier, you next, srceen and Andres about the same level and then Mylo. If Mylo actually is town, then I’d have to rethink some.
oops. didn’t intend to quote that. 
Not too mention - I think the back and forth with him seemed townish. So that left me with, you & Urist. End of day 1, I stopped thinking of mylo as a scum read, due to his posts that seemed so innocent. And then today, he has had the same sort of innocent sounding posts. As he said - why would he lie about putting in a night action haphazardly, and also - not reading the flip!
Now you have claimed vig. And again, I wonder if maybe night kill was skipped because vig kill was put into place instead of night kill …? That seems so weird though. But maybe it could be a ploy on behalf of scum.
I am ready to take mylo off the table though.
Can you tell me exactly why you are townreading Urist? I am kind of too. But, I know he is good as scum.
what do you mean absent that? Absent what?
lol I was tangling two different thoughts there.
- If I subtract out MS spewing him town (if I’m wrong about that)
- If Mylo were to flip town
Re Urist, I don’t feel like the early interactions between him and MS were scum theater. But, I was townreading him yesterday without knowing MS was scum. My reasons for townreading him came down to a couple things - even not knowing MS was scum, I thought Urist looked town in those interactions. There was a moment where I realized/relearned that he has a different and probably better approach to mafia than mine. I get most of my reads through what people post, not through setup spec and thinking about the best way to use abilities as town vs scum. In Urist’s play, I can see that he is weighing all three and I think the way he’s weighing things up looks really town.
I should be a lot more wary of him after the Animals game, but I did learn some things about his scum game and I’m not seeing those things here. And, I also have some confidence about the read because he was a super early townread in the vape game (had to be super early because of the lolhammer). When decided who to send my vape vendor thing to, I didn’t have a second thought.
I kinda always expect that sort of immediate townread to be mutual, even though I have plenty of evidence that people I form early town reads on don’t always townread me. But I was genuinely surprised when I got to the dead thread in that game and saw that Urist was scumreading me from the dead thread on day 2.
thanks for the post : )
But then - why did you say, absent Screen or mylo being scum - Urist would be top tier? Why him over Andres or myself - when you have just stated several reasons as to why Urist looks town to you?
I ask this specifically, because - I DO have mylo and Screen as townish. So I’m looking at who would be next after them. And who others think, beyond them.
So when I read your post, and subtract mylo and Screen - your next is Urist. But given what you just wrote about him - it makes for a conflict.
That’s not what I meant. Top tier as in strongest townread. If Mylo is town, then I need to reevaluate, especially my weaker townreads.
Do you think we should claim?
I’m not sure if that answered your question.
Mantis, you know me. My reads don’t suck. If you’re town and I flip (1v1 ftw!) or night 2, then I really, really hope you’ll take my Mylo read under consideration.
ETA: I can’t answer that. I decided that me claiming would be beneficial because presumably TWO kills didn’t go through last night, and because I hoped it would give me more standing to push Mylo since I didn’t successfully vig him.
Every other player has what they know about the game from their role and any actions. If you think you have something that changes today’s calculus, especially that helps clear someone who could be run up or suggests someone’s lying, then do your best with the info you’ve got.
My gut wants to keep things as opaque for scum as possible, though, in case there’s a night 2.
1 Like
I can see why you want him lynched also, because you never got that resolved for you. VOTE: mylo Willing to trust your judgment
Maybe
<3
Hiyo, I’m backo!
Ahhhh Ffery, why why are you tunneling on me?? Like, I don’t know WHY you scum read me here, especially to such the Undying amount? Like, I’m literally looking through your ISO and I can’t see actual reasons why you’re scumreading me? You ask me a lot of questions, and I answer them, and then you have a disapointed tone in your voice??
Like, I’m sorry but please I just want some reasonings as to why you think I’m scum here. It feels like I’m being caught for something I didn’t do, like I answered all your questions honestly, I put effort in even though it’s easier to lurk and I tried to help gamesolve and not just be an easy mislynch but like you’re still just tunneling on me?