I believed what Andres said. Making me consider that it could be true. And if Andres is town - then ya, maybe MS’s vote on him is opportunistic.
But wasn’t there a moment where there was confusion because you thought he was pushing for a mass claim, but he wasn’t actually? I don’t remember what his response was.
I think my response would be something like: no, I didn’t do that - see here - and then point to what I said. I don’t think I would straight off the bat say that you were shading me. I don’t know if that counts as a point for MS scum
And if I retracted, you’d be ok? I felt like there was an implicit attitude toward me that I was town derping, not that I could be either alignment.
VOTE: MS
You do realize that no matter what this flip is I come back to you
Well… to me you did seem like you were town derping. It looked like that from my end. Anyone could have chimed in and shared you for that
.
Urist gets easier to read as the game goes on I feel. It’s too early for me to judge his clearly over-the-top reaction. That’s just how he starts games though in my (limited) experience - lots of silly interactions and sarcastic comments. He imposes himself more as the game goes on.
–
This seems like an obvious question.
Man, I am not getting good vibes about your slot so far.
–
Huh?
–
Rather self-centered, but okay I might see it? I mean, Mantis was paranoid of me constantly in DS9, and I am seeing some of the same here so far, so that’s good from my perspective.
–
What do you hate about the post? I also think it’s important to think about the setup, because the Scum Team will surely use the setup against us, and we need to be prepared.
Do you mean try and figure out who is who? Absolutely. Wouldn’t you? It’s the first thing I would talk about if I were Scum. Any slip is helpful, since as the game moves on, it will become much easier to identify who is left, and what weakness they might have.
–
This is possible. I am liking Mylo’s posting so far.
–
Does it bother you? This is Srceen we’re talking about here. This is how he plays. And he tends to nail it more often that not, so I give him that too.
–
I see you!
–
Conclusions? I am trying to. Seriously, 200 posts are not a lot. I know Mylo feels differently, but I am not getting a whole lot of vibes from a whole lot of players this game. At least not yet. This game will probably come down to analyzing the voting patterns, which I am not horrible at from past experience, but not my strong suit.
–
You, voting me here, when I have mostly just spoken about the mechanics, and when you have mostly agreed with me, is what makes it Scummy. Though I will give you this, you might be thinking that I am trying to skate by and not post much because other players (who you might think are Town) are attacking each other. But that’s not my play style and you know it. I also have some reason to believe that you do not like being opposite of me in Mafia games. Which is why I dislike this vote. You also have not made any attempt at all to make a case against me. It’s early, so whatever.
–
He won’t, and you shouldn’t expect it. But it’s NAI.
–
You didn’t like being stuck on me when no one else followed?
But we just spent the last bit shooting the shit!
1 Like
Yes, and I thank you for it. It was enjoyable.
1 Like
It didnt
Are you saying I have my play style nailed in?
I think Andres sounds town
@fferyllt I had a thought that you’re inviting ppl to scum read you… or questioning why ppl dont scum read you… as a tactic. Paranoid? Maybe.
I’m not sure. This could actually be his scumgame.
This is what I was saying about ffery. Faulting me for not reading into the motivations behind the implications of her post… is not cool.
I get a lot out of how people react to my posts. Those are the only convos where I know the alignment of one of the players. So yeah, poking at those interactions is definitely a tactic for developing reads.
I was trying to engage you. I can kinda see how that would feel like knocking you down.
I… kinda see it. Mantis did give a valid reason for the slight change in appreciation, in that you almost seemed serious. You saw my comments - I can see how someone might think that. So I do not think Mantis was being disingenuous about her view.
–
Why are you saying this? I literally highlighted the exact same thing, thinking you had claimed.
–
Yeah… sorry for being busy. I really did think I was going to be able to post more. For now, it’s fair enough.
–
I agree, for now.
–
I echo Mantis’ post in #272. Try and help Town if you are Town, for as long as you are Town.
–
Yeah… I also see this. Fferyllt is being a bit guarded in their thinking. Not nearly enough meta on her to make any sort of coherent argument as to whether it fits her Scum play or not, so for now, I will reserve judgment.
–
Hahaha I am saying that more often than not, as Town, you seem very good at spotting the Scum. I would sheep you more often, but I like making up my own mind about things. Almost to my complete detriment.
1 Like
We are never going to get on the same page are we? Regardless of alignment? Nothing new there.
1 Like
Andres I’ll get on the same page! Seems we are reading the same book 
Hey, I townread you for like 95% of the game in ds9, you’re the one who wanted to lynch me!