[Game Thread] SFM1 - Puella Magi Forum★Mafia: Rebellion

@deadbananas Can I get 100 words from you on each of Wisp and Zone?!

Yes it’s fair to say that’s the meat of my argument. Your add-on seemed both preposterous as well as unnecessary since it was fine enough to simply vote him for what would have appeared to you to be a non-sensical vote on arete (and whatever push he made there subsequently). Now I would like @Ari_2412 to give his take on his own play as mafia to lend credence to your testimony that he can do this as scum, swinging at windmills like Don Quixote

Does it matter?? I like take them down better and it more fits the scenario that Ari doesnt end up getting the lynch on Arete but maybe he was trying to throw shade. IDK here its literally just word choice.

My add on was to try to justify why I felt the random vote was more indicative of scum ari in this situation because he does random vote quite often. I can see if I can look through the game where Ari did this and find examples for you but I’m not sure if the game is still up

Also if this doesnt tell you Ari doesnt like the more poweful players idk what does

oh, nothing, it’s just interesting that you used that phrasing

Well I can’t see why he couldn’t do think like this as town or why it’d be more probable he’d carry this feeling as scum more than town

the logic just dosen’t follow, and it’s symptomatic of how bloated your argument for the push was

To be fair to him, the bloat is limited to a single sentence.

there are other arguments i’d regard as simmilarly superfluous

Catching up now
Had an irl situation that needed attending to

this argument makes slightly more sense (still dosen’t really carry but w/e) and is simmiarly overstated

ok? I dont see how that gives +ev in either direction?
I am not removing him from my PoE, but I am getting the feeling that he just believes his paranioa, and isnt pushing it maliciously, not that he cant be right, but I think given everything so far, looking for a deep wolf in the top posters, is less likely to be a hit as it stands

@Icibalus If bananas is scum, either one of us should be able to catch him out on his reads on Wisp and Zone!

I think we disagree in logic here. If you want to vote me for that theres not really anything that arguement wise I can do to dissuade you. I’m going to focus on trying to solve the game at this point because that’s the best way for me to prove innocent to you guys if we disagree on logic

@deadbananas

exactly 100 words, no more no less

1 Like

Sure, i’ll take that bet.

Oh sorry must of missed that, not sure I can promise you 100 words on each but I’ll try.

deadbananas feels like datbird in Ritual Mafia 2, a game on ToL.
let me bring that up