I don’t underestimate Zone. I may be overestimating Arete
Its possible he’s trying to hide the fact he has TMI
But what does him being icibalus, have to do anything?
Yes this has been ActionDan. I probably should sign my posts from now on though I prefer hydras to present as unified in general.
~AD
Doubtful, but you aren’t even giving him a chance
Your read reads like, “he looks good, but icibalus is a strong player as both alignments, so it means nothing”
And I’m not saying he can’t be a wolf, but these string of posts tell a different story
Zone doesn’t need that help as scum, I think!
Because it means that having reasons that sound good on paper isn’t a reason to townread him, and also that specific tone-adjacent things that only apply to Ici can be used to read him
also I have to go to class now
I read Ari is being disconnected cuz its Ari. I know from experience that he would often do his own thing while on a scumteam with me. That’s why I’m reading him as estranged. Ari recommended killing big players in chat, and also went and tried to start votes on them on his own. Ari likes to take out the bigger players, this is where I think its based on. I dont follow your logic with the TMI thing as all still for me not wanting to think about scum chat. I think you’ve explained it the best you can but the logic is just bad or I’m dumb.
His reads feel fake
I’m not sure what it is about them that feels fake but it’s something
Def agree with underestimating zone makes him appear more town. However his push on Arete still gives me vibes from my past game when we were scum. He’s the best lead I have right now. Who do you think is the most scum and why?
The way you phrased it “recommended taking down big players” implies he would have liked them taken down, e.g, being successful in his push. being right in that he pushed arete this game does not cause him to be scum.
i was writing a big post but this sums my point up a bit more succinctly- in no world does this logic lead to a vote unless you’re simply not considering it properly!
But it’s certainly not a reason to vote him?
Votecount as of post #612
bepwei (3): Geyde, Valerie, Quin
deadbananas (3): TotallyNotKyubey, Icibalus, Wisp
Icibalus (2): Marshal, Arete
Marshal (2): REM, Zone_Q11
Ari_2412 (1): deadbananas
IronicDeadBird (1): bepwei
Not Voting (5): IronicDeadBird, EricKline, Chemist1422, ash4fun, Ari_2412
arete this feels a bit like “ici is a wolf because i’ve seen into his soul and he has that three wolf shirt from amazon that has all those funny reviews which is being worn by his dream self mindghost”
1 Like
That’s my bad. I meant by him recommending to take down big players that Ari likes to vote for them try to take them down. I mainly interpreted your reasoning for voting me off of this
I assumed this was the meat of your argument against me, that he wasnt getting arete so therefore my read of him being scum for trying to take down a powerful player like he does while scum was wrong so I sought to prove he was in fact trying to do that. If this isnt your argument against me could you tell me what is?
why the phrasing “take them down”? why not “kill”?
Unless I see something spicy, my POE is below!
Ironic - bepwei > deadbananas > Icibalus > Ari > quin > Marshal - Zone
Eric and Arete are town if and only if one of the masons flips town before f7!
I love you for this post no matter what your alignment is!
god i’m so bad at describing why the logic fails
i just know that there’s TMI in that push
i could probably justify it on a better day
1 Like
If your looking for more reasoning as to why that logic lead to a vote then read the beginning of the post. I agreed that we needed a wagon going and I thought Ari was the best one to start due to the reasoning that you guys have already looked at.