fyi this is all of my contents from reading through thread sporadically for the first time
Didn’t know I was in Alison’s slot atp so take that as you may
Summary
(going to be posting thoughts in regard to the game here because I’m reading up atm)
Feeling big scum energy from Zone https://www.chiefdelphi.com/t/game-thread-sfm1-puella-magi-forum-mafia/371358/65 https://www.chiefdelphi.com/t/game-thread-sfm1-puella-magi-forum-mafia/371358/80 https://www.chiefdelphi.com/t/game-thread-sfm1-puella-magi-forum-mafia/371358/85
Actually, take that back
Big town feels
Mostly based on meta given that absurd behavior is something predominantly done by his town game rather than scum game. This is just a different form of absurd behavior.
I don’t get the support for town marshal
He’s rather null and a lot of his plays leave a lot to be desired
He’s certainly trying to read players, but his comments aren’t particularly insightful nor does he have particularly good associations with any flipped players.
Certainly not leaning either way
litten likely spk
(and they were pretty obvtown)
Quin’s post is very brave. Need to check past games to cross reference behavior
Plus this setup definitely has slank vig
gellnick’s vote on useless is super agenda driven
Definitely taking advantage of thread absolutely hating them
Thread warps around Useless as a natural shit disturber. Very useful to look in people not really caring about the slot for scum.
Quarky very likely sideline scum
Feel ok-ish about Marshal post useless, but they still aren’t pushing gamestate forward in a meaningful manner
Aren’t actually reading people
Arete is alright
Like not locktown but definitely want to see where their influence causes game direction to go
Basically at same place in thread as Valerie (#1289)
Possibly just pushing a narrative
But I like the slot’s content so far
Nibio/Gellnick/Alison/Erik are a pile that needs a lot of focus
There’s a wolf trying to stay above water there
Actually disagree with above point
Nibio/Gellnick/Alison/Erik are definitely worth a considerable focus, but I think more because they are in a constant battle amongst themselves
Valerie needs to follow up for me to townread their slot
I feel relatively good about it but definitely not lock territory
Same thing about Arete
Arete didn’t really push NB
So scum for me I think:
NB (already flipped)
Scout/quarky (vote was horrible in context of flips, hasn’t been taken advantage of despite the fighting all around thread)
Somewhere in Nibio/Gellnick/Alison/Erik
Possibly more from that pile?
Town (of varying levels whatever)
REM (haven’t carefully read)
Arete
ash (mild on this, haven’t read slot)
IronicDeadBird (don’t bluestorm me, I’ll check back later)
Valerie
Zone
Fairly substantial chunk of town for this point in the game
Bep’s posts during the d1 weird shenaniganza are undeniably weird
Nuclear not focusing at all on other people in thread strikes me as particularly telling, but I’m not sure what that tells
Valerie’s handling of Quin’s slot being met with numerous scumreads of them seems mildly opportunistic
It’s a controversial take
And people seem to be taking advantage of it
Feel deepwolf potential from Alison
Nibio/Alison are bickering heavily
Change my mind on Nibio
Very high town
That wall has a lot of analysis that I like
Dropping lower to lean town
Good but could be done by scum and had some hedge
Agree with Squirrel’s points about Quin’s slot a lot more than anyone else’s points
hmm i might as well introduce myself (although i kind of did in the signup thread already)
i’m sunbell, i’m from team 253 (not 254, sadly). i’ve never played forum mafia before but my team plays irl mafia with each other a lot, so hopefully i won’t have too hard of a time here?
i’ve replaced scout6088, so quarky and i are sharing this account. i don’t think quarky has migrated to mafia451 yet so for now it’s just me actually
EricKline doesn’t want to confirm nor deny the existence of the neighborhood that Arete is claiming to be in. We -or at the very least myself- are at a point where it is pretty obvious that he is in one. It’s annoying that he won’t confirm nor deny the existence, as it shows that he is not cooperating with us.
Think about it. What reason is there for him to not confirm nor deny this statement?
–oh also, @Ari_2412 and I are Village Idiots who think that each other are scum. No surprise here, really.
they* literally just copy and pasted the OP of neighborhood, which is uhmm, super [redacted]
so it exists, the problem is their alignments, and if the opener means anything
but for now, we should not be focusing on them