[Game Thread] SFM1 - Puella Magi Forum★Mafia: Rebellion

(I may be around a little, but not much.)

I can do it, I think

Public claims
1: REM - Mason/neighbor
2: Arete - Mason/neighbor
3: Litten Eliminated D1 - H.N. Elly (Kirsten), Witch Rolestopper
4: ash4fun - Gunsmith
5: Bepwei - Vanillarized mechanics oracle/public messenger
6: IronicDeadBird
7: quin - Universal Backup
8: EricKline - Mason/neighbor
9: gellnick Icibalus - lynched N2 - Acetic IC/Arsonist
10: darth_tabor Valerie - conditional vig
11: Squirrel2412 Chemist1422 - neighborizer
12: Nibio - investigative of some sort
13: NuclearBurrito Eliminated D1 - Homura Akemi, Magical Girl Ninja/1-Shot Paralyzer/3-Shot Janitor
14: Marshal - daytalk enabler + magnet
15: SlayerBoy26 Deadbananas - backup for Ash
16: Zone_Q11 - shot N2, flipped town tracker
17: Scout6088 sunbell/quarky - died D2, flipped town bus driver
18: Alison Geyde
19: USELESS - Modkilled N1 - Gisela, Witch Tracker
20: Operator_Chan GoalkeeperBoss - Eliminated N1 - Gertrud, Witch Jailkeeper
21: Juckproty Ari_2412 - died D2, flipped town parity cop

2 Likes

Thank you!

Too many informative/confirmable roles.

Ari
Ash
Bepwei
Chemist
Hydra
Icibalus
Marshal
Masons
Nibio
Useless
Valerie
Zone

1 Like

My thought is wolves maybe don’t want to hit the Mason’s cause it confirms them, and if that is true it’s most likely that none of them are wolves, else I think they would certainly do it

UNVOTE

I kind of think Marshal could be scum with a role designed to look townie to mess up mechconfirms

His claim is basically the towniest thing about him

1 Like

btw I’m busy but reading/catching up occasionally.
carry on…

I forgot about Marshal honestly, but I need to re-evalute my town lean on him if I am to believe the masonry is all town

@bepwei
Why do you think I am town? And I want like a well thought out read, and not something like, “well you feel like you trying to solve the game”

REM
Arete
ash4fun
Bepwei
IronicDeadBird
quin
EricKline
Valerie (i am losing to this slot if he is a wolf)
Chemist1422
Marshal
Deadbananas
Geyde

if I believe Ash is town, then unless deadbananas has a fake claim, then he is probably town
Bepwei
IronicDeadBird
quin
Chemist1422
Marshal
Geyde

Squirrel was hella townie, with some consistent game solving that makes me feel like this slot is town regardless Chem, who is honestly super NAI at this point
Bepwei
IronicDeadBird
quin
Marshal
Geyde

don’t think I am confident in removing anyone else right now, Geyde is probably at the top of the list though, and not the first one I would ever lynch

But ash is still a problem, everything surrounding me is quite consistent, her reasons for suspecting ici, and thinking dead is town (the whole mechanical thing as well), but like I don’t understand what happened here, for her to get this check on me

this game has too many investigative roles, plus confirmable information, so like if that is true, then the wolves are super strong, and I guess it is possible that they have a role that could affect the information an investigative role gets, even if I think its bastard

GoalkeeperBoss 9 REM Litten ash4fun Valerie Squirrel2412 Marshal Zone_Q11 Scout6088/quarky Alison
quin 4 Arete EricKline Nibio Ari_2412
Not Voting 3 Bepwei gellnick NuclearBurrito
EricKline 2 IronicDeadBird Deadbananas
Valerie 1 quin
Marshal 1 GoalkeeperBoss

this is where I am at given my thoughts right now
one thing to note, the quin wagon is completely clean

Man nobody killed me for drunk posting?

I think this is where I am right now
VOTE: Marshal

its nai

God I’m annoyed reading it and I said it lol.

I think Marshal is the wolf!ascetic, especially given the ninja passive on it

im fullclaiming cause im a fucking idiot who wants innocent children dead

im a 1-shot party host/magnet

my first abil allows people to talk during day(used it for d1)

my 2nd one redirects a person to myself(without showing as a visit for whatever reason)

@ash4fun
sorry to ask this again, but you are sure you message clearly said I had a gun?
I am starting to think maybe you got targeted by Marshal, and he is a wolf, that would explain everything

since night 1, you were talking to chemist? and he knew your ability, especially your target?

@Valerie what do you think? I think Chemist is probably a wolf here, or marshal completely winged this target

She.

honestly this is why I should just stop using pronouns
also I am removing Squirrel from my town leans until I am confident in this read

I’m down to lynch either of Chemist or Marshal. I think Marshal is more directly suspicious.

@Valerie
yo, who is in the neighborhood
Ash/Chem? and who else?