Bepwei is also a problem, I really did not like his vote on Seth
Why?
I mean
Squirrel’s Iso still feels townie
but also the wolves have to be somewhere
@Seththeking
Yo, tell me why you vitedt Geyde, please
You make me paranoid with stuff like that
I don’t trust the confidence
wait did he visit geyde D1 or D2?
(does that explain my “no result”?)
Eric is town
Rem is also town
more specifically, even if we ignore that they’re both also Lost Familiars: Eric seemed to genuinely think that witches were scum at SoG, and his way of handling things like the fact that I was a claimed witch in-neighborhood only make sense from the perspective of a witch who thinks they’re scum, not from any other perspective. (He also had some posts around the gap that make literally no sense from scum but some of that gets kind of angleshooty).
Rem’s just been super pure and I feel like we’ve mindmelded several times in a way that I don’t think she could convincingly fake as scum
Why is Geyde a wolf? Specifically why is he more likely than Chemist to be a wolf?
What could you possibly get from my answers here? Witch and exterminate the magic girls
Because if Chemist is scum then they’re probably just a neighborizor, if we want a chance at winning we need to take out the claimvig asap.
With how loaded Nuclear was I would expect scum!Mist to have more than just a neighborizer ability although claimvig + neighborizer doesn’t really fit
Did you have a specific reason for thinking that Geyde was exactly claimvig?
Not really no
Sorry if you these questions are stupid, I just want to see what everyone’s top PoE
Not directed to me, but
- Wisp
- Bepwei
- Geyde
- Ironicdeadbird
and
- Chemist1422
- quin
- seththeking
- X
where I guess X is one of my PoE 
:
chemist1422
Bepwei
IronicDeadBird
quin
Marshal/sethTheKing
Alison/geyde
Nibio
sorted roughly by my read of them.
Spent the first few days researching mechanical info because that would be the easiest for me to comprehend. Didn’t turn up anything amazingly useful now I actually have to iso…
Would it be possible the neighborhood of three to be 2 scum 1 town?
Did we confirm whose in the chat with EK, and Arete? Cause EKs stubbornness in admitting there is or isn’t a neighborhood feels alignment indicative in some weird way.
I’m not sure I agree with Bepweis thought process and survival process with the given skill set, you could have included the claim kill mechanic thing instead of clearing yourself in the mental message but you chose to push that info out personally in thread . I’m newish to mafia so my understanding is that most people don’t claim upfront they claim when they are worried they are going to be lynched.
So much to review so little time.
Votecount as of post #2411
Nanook (4): REM, Wisp, Seththeking, Chemist1422
Wisp (3): Quin, ash4fun, deadbananas
Chemist1422 (2): Valerie, Arete
Not Voting (4): IronicDeadBird, Nanook, EricKline, bepwei
Hi guys. I’m probably (definitely) not gonna read this whole thread, ping me if you want me otherwise I’ll see you at 7 players 
you’re top wagon
2 Likes
Also Wisp I’m answering your question but will probably be delayed in actually posting it until after I get off a plane
Really… I hate replacements
4 Likes