Flip Flappers Mafia [TOWN WIN]

This is a some what towny point.

Once again Nanook, replacement players are coming in to slots that looked scummy.
You as Val have been in the Top Two Bandwagons Two days in a row.
Perhaps I am not reacting to you quit fairly.

Fucked if I know.:grin::rofl:

I mean, if I ask a question, then say ā€œAnd oh yeah, if you answer this question one way iā€™ll think youā€™re scum, but Iā€™ll think youā€™re town if you answer it differently,ā€ then thereā€™s not really a point to asking the question to begin with.

How far are you tho? I want to hear your thoughts as you think them.

I literally just started.

#NanookIsLazy

I havenā€™t played with you then. :joy:

Iā€™ll try and pull out things that ping me as I read them, and post them a couple at a time so theyā€™re not too disjointed but also not in one huge long post

Okay, Even with Urist convincing me yesterday that your slot was not scum, I still am thinking of you and reacting to you as scum.

I may be at fault and not responding fairly.

Can you give me an update of your thoughts on the players when you get to the end of day one? Please and thanks? With whipped cream and cherries and scrumptious gooseberries?

Iā€™m ok with playing this day as a Catspurr is scum but not getting lynched kind of a day. Either way they are self resolving now.

Will do so if I remember haha.

Srceenie if you assume that catspurr is town then who is scum?

Was thinking you and Elli.
But idk.

Iā€™m honestly going to have to iso again.

Up to 104. Erika looks townie to me. Like the early poking.

I have been wondering about Elli all this game.
His style of play, not giving anything away as town, makes it easier for him to be scum.

My only point in his favour is, If Elli was scum would you expect him to be the one putting in the kill?
I would think yes, but then he may be used to being investigated night one?

Let me go back and look at the vote count again - I thought it had been fully updated (but you are probably right - it seemed off since after catspurr pulled her vote, then Val would have been L-2 without any other changes).

And btw, I agree that lynching someone who flips Town yields valuable information. But my point was a little more nuanced. I think it matters a great deal how that person is lynched. If you have a view that someone is Town, and yet you vote for them to get lynched after saying that you think that they are Town (and they do flip Town), then you look like you are covering your ass while voting against Town (and this is not even that complicated - itā€™s exactly what I would expect Scum to do). And so your ability to argue against someone else who you suspect is driving the mislynch is greatly diminished. So you put us in a tough spot. And thatā€™s not even taking into account the fact that you could be wrong about the person you are suspicious of in the first place. So isnā€™t it better to form a collective view of who could be Scum, and start there? Thatā€™s what Iā€™ve been trying to get at all this time. So weā€™ll have to agree to disagree, but youā€™ll see why Iā€™m deeply skeptical of what youā€™re arguing for.

Also liking Elli so far (up to post 175 now, Iā€™ve been getting distracted a lot).

Post 195 reallllly rubs me the wrong way. Not liking catspurr at all with this, ā€œEnd the day and get it over withā€ isnā€™t really a townie perspective FMPOV.

hey

val and mohabā€™s replacement are scum

VOTE: Val

so are u calling Rica scum