Dengeki Bunko UCanPick [TOWN + SURVIVOR WIN]

[catspurr]

No one visited Erika?
And yet she was killed?

Seems strange.
But also seems a strange claim for scum to make.

[catspurr]

I’m not sure about this.
The most they would be able to kill would be two.
Masons seem to be a pair.
Srceen claims his neighbourising ability was cut down to one shot.

Town have a lot of scatter shot roles like Neymar/Cheekies.

[catspurr]

^cheekies multikill power was One Shot Limited.

[catspurr]

I had a role which failed last night.
The GM reported to me that it Failed.

Skitter and RedFlavour.
What was your reports from the GM like?
Dd they say no action seen or no results or what?

[catspurr]

The reason I ask is because it 'Failed" and my target has not been claimed as a target of any other town special.

So why did my power fail?
Was my target protected in whihc case it could be a scummy protection from just that target?
Or was I caught up in a scum power like what stoped Redflavour from seeing Erika killed?

[skitter30]

i didn’t get a response from the mod

[catspurr]

Thanks Skitter.
RedFlavour, where you told you saw nothing?

I have a feeling that the one scum might be right and that they have something like what Nanook claims. A power to blanket block all powers.

But it is only one idea.
I will tell you what my one shot power was.

I could target any player and the next Day there alignment would be announced.
As I say, I got a report from MS, Failed.

Why?
We know we have roleblockers jk’s in this game.

[DS (SFwordsmith.com / https://discord.gg/3NmUdv2)]

Skitter just being a straight up JK doesn’t quite vibe with what we’ve seen so far from the role flips (with knowledge of my own role also) though I’m hard pressed to believe a scum partner claimed their scum partners claim lol

[Nanook (Clem)]

Ok, here and catching up. Probably won’t get caught all the way up, but I also stay up much too late on halloween so I’m sure I’ll probably find the time to finish whatever I don’t get to tomorrow.

[Nanook (Clem)]

100% voting Cheeky over Srceenplay today because Urist is confirming Srceenplays action which is also confirmed with Erika’s. We know that Srceenplay did an action but did not kill anyone last night, so at the very least he is not the lynch today.

I still think there are better options than Cheeky but if it is between those two we lynch cheeky

Correct outcome, horrible logic. Screenplay couldn’t have killed anyone N1 due to my role, so his taking an action without anyone dying is in no way actually AI.

[Nanook (Clem)]

It seems to me that there’s a world here where DS is scum trying to guide the lynch onto the players whose roles he knows less about. His posts in the 1630s and 40s kinda strike me as weird from that POV. Not sure if that’s a world I buy into, but it’s worth considering.

[Nanook (Clem)]

I also forget where his vote ended at EOD, and if he jumped onto Cheeky, when he did so. So take that with a grain of salt.

[Nanook (Clem)]

I am still new to pluraity voting. The majority of my games over the years have been majority.
When we need 7 votes to lynch, does not having two wagons mean a lynch is less likely?
I was okay with no lynch yesterday.
But we need a lynch today.

Uh…I seem to recall you vastly preferring Plurality lynch and bitching about the transition from plurality to majority in the past? Am I hallucinating?

[Nanook (Clem)]

Nevermind.

[Nanook (Clem)]

i highly highly highly doubt that there are two jks tbh

best guess is that scum were informed that there is one and she didn’t realized it was claimed and was trying to force a cc or something?

…how does this make sense? Are scum normally informed what roles are in a game while town aren’t? I don’t get it, is this a thing that happens?

[Nanook (Clem)]

It does look to me like cheeky caught themsleves out by not reading the thread.
BUT, with probably three scum, it is funny one of them was not reading the thread better and caught the claim.

I mean it would have been a lot better for cheeky to counter claim rather than just put it out there without knowing someoen else had claimed.

I am thinking that, we have a distracted scum team.
Maybe Andre, Cheeky and Rily?

Andre is now in my maybe scum list because of this distracted scum theory I have just come up with.
And yes, I could be talking out of my bum.

1. I know for a fact you don’t always use the scumboard, or use it sparsely, not sure why you expect differently from others

2. This seems like a convenient way to avoid making reads, by saying “it’s probably just the lurkers.”

It’s just a lot to read in. Like, some scum teams play as a team and help each other out like that, and some play as individuals. I’m not real comfortable assuming one or the other (and it seems especially silly to do so before you have a flip, as you were doing here), it just seems like the kind of assumption that’s super easy to get off the rails with.

[Nanook (Clem)]

1740s and 50s, don’t love Urist’s defending of Cheeky. Feels…reachy. Hard to say how much 20/20 hindsight is involved in that, though.

[Nanook (Clem)]

Scum team is probably Riley Cake, Cheeky, Nanook

2/3 ain’t bad

[Nanook (Clem)]

Nanook looks horrible here if Cheeky flips scum. It has to be assumed that he was saving Neymar and his role was designed to trade the night kill for protecting one of his own from lynch

This is demonstrably silly, since scumNanook could’ve done that in a much better and more efficient way that didn’t use up his role. Like…do we really have to cover this same ground again?

[Nanook (Clem)]

Ok, that brings me up to 1792. Was hoping to finish catching up on D2 this morning, but that’s not happening at this point. Will try to finish catching up tonight.