Its interesting (for me) that DS mentioned the MU champ games. You know his scum team won the finale game by a clean sweep… scum worked together in thread to steamroll town and didnt get mislynched.
So re scum blantanly working in thread together. Yes, they very much can. (In regards to skitter and DS). Just putting that out there
She words things carefully, but her actual play hasn’t been careful. She zeroed in on her scumread and stuck to her guns, that’s a lot different than the skitter I recall playing with who was really super cautious about votes.
That logic is backwards.
I also enjoy how on this site I get scumread for being too emotional and not emotional enough.
And it does still bother me that skitter said things like she just finds DS very town and very genuine. I just dont get that at all. Probably because I dont see that at all. Like we’re not reading the same game
I’m telling you what it felt like. It didnt feel like you believed it. Theres not really logic there to begin with. Gut
But then again, skitters was sort of questioning ds role saying “ngl sounds like a scum role” so seems less likely to say that to a partner
The last part, the if Neymar is scum Nanook probably is too, is where the logic is bad.
The rest…I mean, like, I think it’s just an unfair read to say “Nanook is scum because he doesn’t seem emotional enough” when there are so many things that can effect that, including but not limited to Nanook playing on his phone between other stuff, Nanook not being as deeply invested in this game as some others, Nanook playing a lot quicker than he usually does, mantis not reading Nanook’s tone correctly, this being a read Nanook has come to over time rather than a snap read…and any other number of other things.
So yeah, I’m not sure that’s really a totally fair read, but it is the kind of read that’s good to make as scum, so I guess I can’t hold it against you too much.
Ok, that kinda affects my townread on you - i think i was assuming you were a new player and in that context your actions seem very genuine, but then i realized i didnt actually know if that was true.
Yeah but ill cross that bridge when i get to it
Explain how you think im still playing cautiously
^^^^^
Like I word things carefully and I only really strongly push people when I have strong feelings about them, but despite that, I wouldnt really characterize my play this game overall as ‘cautious’ or ‘careful’
Ok. Ya maybe its wrong. I mean… you are also reading me wrong if you are town 
Can you look outside of me? Who in that case would you think? Do you really trust DS is town?
VOTE: skitter30
I’S DON’T LIKE YA PUSH ON NANOOK!!! THAT ROLES DOESN’T MAKE SENSE FOR SCUM TA HAVE!!! AND IT SEEMS LIKE YA ARE TRYING TA BREAK UP A CONFIRMED TOWNIESIES
Yeah I don’t understand why Nanook hasn’t voted for you today, and why he didn’t vote for you yesterday.
I disagree that it doesn’t make sense for scum to have and I disagree that I was doing that
She has been super cautious about votes. She didn’t vote for Mantis until someone else expressed a scum read on her, for example. She sat on Mantis forever without making a strong push on her, for another example.
And I don’t understand why you keep bringing up the one game you played with her where she was scum, she posted like 8 times. And those posts make you a skitter meta savant. Give me a break. Please stop pretending that scum can’t act differently from game to game and actually take a look at her play independent of this shitty meta read that you have on her.
dear god, how is it that riley cake is the only other person in this game with an ounce of sense in their body
VOTE: skitter30
“i want to call you town but want to keep my options open in case a wagon builds on you”.
even if we assume you’re town, this is a cautious way to play the game.
just pick a read, town or scum, and be done with it.
Yeah ok you say “really strongly push” but in reality I don’t think you’ve gone after anybody with any degree of bite.
there are two ways to play mafia:
guess which one you are.
and guess which one i am.
the above is a reply to this post here (990)
This is a playstyle thing; this isnt ai for me
You realize that you’re complaining that I scumread someone for their like second post and that I’m scummy for not moving on or reconsidering and that I’m tunneling and you’re doing prerry much the same thing, right?
I thought she was behaving in a scummy fashion. Other people agreed. I voted her. I disagree this indicates that I was being cautious or waiting for other people to approve or whatever (if i was, i would have waited until a wagon started or something)
I think you’re overly focused on one post from an entire dayphase ago and ignoring my olay in a broader context (yes, please explain how the argument I had with nanook last night fits my cautiois playstyle; i literally never have arguments like that as scum)
He’s right; i avoid real-time whenever possible as scum
Not something i can do easily.