wheme doesn’t believe xrosen truly had no opinions about anything that had happened yesterday, especially given their background of having played mafia before. Similar to the argument Elwood made but less matured probably.
Srceenplay agrees with me on the majority of my poe and is happy just bashing the stragglers.
Tier isn’t paying that much attention but he almost certainly doesn’t just yolo skip the night as scum there and then he claim he did it so he already did his job by getting himself off the list.
Wheme probably didn’t think of things this deeply anyways - the extent of his thought process was probably seeing that rosen was capable of reasoned arguments about the theory of the game but declined to call anything indicative of anything for the entirety of D1. Do I agree with his conclusion? Less so, but I think the thought process is relatively understandable.