Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

Who would you want to lynch the most among nanook smilodon ad?

super hung over and dstill kinda high needa sober uf pfor workikll be here tomorrow

Let’s go through this once.

You voted for MS.

MS said:

Mantis agreed, and so did you:

So here, you are suggesting that among the other players that are on the wagon, there could be Scum. Mantis then asks:

And you respond:

So let me get this straight. Out of the three players on a wagon for potential Scum you have voted for, two of those players could also be Scum?

Immediately the following questions came to mind:
(i) what was the rationale behind your vote for MS?
(ii) why would you engage in this back and forth without questioning where MS is coming from? Obviously Scum is going to want to frame any voting on them as Scummy, unless you expect them to roll over and die. But instead, you entertain the thought without once saying “well, MS is probably Scum and lying so I don’t think this is worth pursuing”. This is what is justifying my belief that your vote on MS was not well thought out.
(iii) if Mantis is Town reading MS, and thinks that the wagon on MS contains Scum, why do you think she is not questioning your vote? But only questions Srceenplay and mine? She’s focusing on half the wagon, and speaking of two players of which one, she already said she has a Town read on (#1286). Like what makes my vote so different from Josh’s or yours? Srceenplay fine, she was null/negative lean, whatever. But why mention me then?

Why did you agree here? But have yet to question Mantis’ vote on Srceenplay?

@Urist, this is hypocritical:

Like if you are not willing to compromise on your lynch target, then why should other people?

When something doesn’t make sense, I’ll ask. It’s NAI. I can tell you that right now.

This is a lot of hedging, but thank you nonetheless. At least I know I’m not completely insane.

I was just fooling around by quoting Judge’s post back at her. I’m willing to compromise, but I don’t see the need when my preferred lynch already has the most votes.

You don’t read sarcasm very well, do you?

Make your point.

Okay fine.

I completely missed that you would vote yourself hahaha okay that’s just stupid. Ignore.

1 Like

I’m traveling today and will be phone-modding. Please bear with me during this great travail.

Hahahahaha oh wow, I need to go hide behind a rock.

1 Like

I thought the deadline was tonight at midnight. So you catching up tomorrow probably doesn’t work.


that was my point. That you missed Urist’s sarcasm.

It’s not s criticism, just a comment.

Yeah
 fair enough. I still woke up confused clearly. I would normally catch that, I promise.

VC 1-40

Josh: 3 (Urist, Metal Sonic, Cabd)
Mantis: 1 (Srceenplay)
Metal Sonic: 1 (Josh)
Nanook: 1 (catspurr)
catspurr: 1 (Nanook)
_fferyllt: 1 (Judge Mental)
Srceenplay: 1 (Mantis)

Not voting: 4 (smilodon, _fferyllt, pyx, Andresvmb)

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: August 13, 2018 4:00 AM

This topic will close automatically 30 minutes after the deadline.

Mod Notes:

  • :slight_smile:

If Andres is ever thinking of self-voting he needs to internalise that I’m Cardassian and he early on posted this:

Sure, this is entirely within the realm of possibility.

You know, I’ll let you guys decide what the viable wagons should be and I’ll make up my mind later. I’ll be around. MS is off the table for me today. I don’t know how I should see Josh anymore, but my first instincts were pointing to Town. However, my instincts don’t seem to be that good so who knows. Srceen could be buddying me up. That’s entirely possible. Like Nanook says, Judge’s progression, which rings suspicious to me, might be completely innocuous. So I don’t really know where I’ll land. Scum could be having a laugh at my arguments because I’ve completely missed them. I’m still null on certain players and that’s rather annoying. I know I’m not voting Urist. Or _fferyllt probably.

Hahahaha I’m glad you are playing with us, Pyx. Your predecessor was tunneling me the entire day. Where do you think you’ll end up?

Probably in a cloud.

?