SHOULD BE, Or Not IF she is scum…
No, it’s totally different. First of all, Andres said that either one of you are scum, or you
Andres said that either you’re both town, or one is scum, both not both. parsec is saying that exactly one of us is scum. That’s the difference.
I was gonna make another argument but it really doesn’t matter. I only took issue with it because I think Josh might be town.
My hero
1 Like
You have no vote out at present. Can you be bribed to join the wagon for the low low price of three easy payments of $19.99?
You’re going to pay me? Very well, I accept.
(Not really)
I don’t even know why you’re voting Nanook in the first place.
FTFY
Btw being boring seems like an amazing way to stir up town apathy.
Besides, I said you were unoriginal and safe, not boring.
I say this because I doubt anyone is going to question those reads, they’re uninsightful at best, and leaving cats as a backup lynch in case the Nanook wagon doesn’t pan out seems like a solid strategy.
Sure, a not well thought out vote is more likely to be from Town, I would agree. But that ignores context. Srceenplay looked like he was looking for a crappy excuse to get a vote on Cats, who would have been sitting at L-2. That’s a dangerous spot to put someone in, so it would also make sense as Town that you would try and have some sort of rationale for said vote.
I don’t know what to make of Srceenplay pulling said vote after questioning from Muffin, Cats and I. Scum might have looked to maintain the vote for a bit longer (I know I would have tried). So the quick change could be a sign that Srceenplay agreed with what was said and pulled back. It could also simply be a reaction to avoid further scrutiny. I don’t know.
Wait, hold on. Isn’t Srceen maintaining that his claim clears Cats? So how do you explain any vote on Cats? I mean, this definitely eliminates any possibility of that claim being true, that’s for sure.
Lol. It feels like you and nanook changed good cop bad cop positions.
You think none of those reads are going to be controversial? I feel like if we go based on the general consensus I can spot at least two townreads of mine that have been wagoned or talked about as scumreads by and large, but let’s go with “Cabd has boring reads” and let’s talk about how that particularly makes them more likely to be wrong in any way shape or form? Or am i not understanding your point correctly?
In the end, I just want to poke life back into the game. And so that’s what i’m doing.
My point is not that they’re more likely to be wrong, just that it’s a very easy list to post if you’re scum trying to get by with as little effort as possible.
If you actually want to poke life into the game, I would recommend posting the reasoning behind your Nanook read so that we have something else to discuss, as you’ve been asked to do multiple times now.
Of the 8 people who have posted since your reads list, only 2 people acknowledged it, and the only thing we’ve asked you about is your read on Nanook. So yeah, I’d say they’re pretty uncontroversial.
If you want to start controversy, you have to provide reasons. A reads list without reasons is like a bathroom without a toilet. Nobody’s going to give a shit.
2 Likes
You were presented with multiple opportunities to do exactly this.
You can still tell us, what else was behind your vote?
Re-read post 81 and a few of their posts around it; then compare that to the posts around the “claim”
And see what you think comparing those two in isolation. I think you’ll find that whenever Nanook gets at all off their comfort zone, they tend to overtalk and overexplain to the point of trying to tamp down on every angle and tangent pre-emptively.
We already went through this.
Also, has Nanook played games with ffery as mod before? Important for a reason to be specified after answered.
By the by Screenplay, how strong is YOUR dan scumread, like… cop guilty vs gut ping, where are you on that scale?
Can you acknowledge your claim is a complete fabrication now? You can at least do that.