So maybe you are the Scum? Interesting. Why do you want us to lynch the strongest Town claim left?
Because, despite his claim (which is too heavy to have as town) - he is scummy. Plain and simple.
are you really gonna start accusing mantis now
you canât accuse everybody.
Et tu Brutus?
I come not to Praise Srceenplay but to point out that it is too soon to call his bluff.
CCause I really find it harder to belive it is a bluff than to see urist as the villian trying to lynch town.
Why not?
We donât know who is town and who is scum.
You wonât belive what I see as a water tight claim.
He probably no killed in order to make it to lylo. And be cleared. And then ⊠with his role, he can explain never getting nightkilled by âprotecting/hiding within a playerâ
Think about it. He can never be night killed.
1 Like
^itâs the perfect way to get by and to explain not getting night killed.
1 Like
We lynch Srceenplay today.
1 Like
This is a reasonable argument.:shrug:
It does not explain what has been happening to Metal.
Screenplay canât be nightkilled and has a possessor power?
UNVOTE: URIST
I want to hear from Metal, Josh and who else are we missing?
No he SAYS he has protection and thus canât be nightkilled.
But in actually reality⊠he has another role. Maybe possessor. But maybe MS has some little thing going on, on his own. I have no idea.
As said, MS DIDNâT actually need to get repossessed. In MSâs initial claim - he slept walked. But he said, in the PM from ffery, it never said that he went near _ffery/muffins.
We all thought it was possessor, because cabd claimed tracker and said that MS visited muffins. But, cabd was NOT tracker, and so, MS didnât visit muffins⊠(necessarily).
As to why he is still sleepwalking⊠again, maybe that is a passive town role⊠where he sleep walks until he gets something. Who knows, because MS has decided not to claim his role! Which is a bit frustratingâŠ
1 Like
No itâs not a good argument.
A good argument is we canât let srceenplay into lylo.
Lynching a doc after they stopped a kill is bad play anyway you look at it in this situation.
Even if you are 90% sure Iâm scum you donât lynch me here.
what if iâm 92% sure?
us robots deal with very precise arithmetic dontchaknow
Iâm done with you
@catspurr this is the more reasonable argument why Screen could be scum. Think about it⊠we let him go, on his word that he is the doctor. We excuse him never being night killed, because he can just claim that he âsymbioticallyâ merged into someone, and got protected⊠and that the person he merged into âmustâ have been the target for the night kill.
So you see ? He claims to essentially be night kill immune. Which is a pretty damn good excuse for a scum, who claims to be doctor, to still be alive at end game.
donât pretend to be mad at me just because iâm calling you out on your bs claim
Iâll vote pyx or urist today.
Mechanicly it should probably be pyx.
Emotionally it should be pyx.
Again Iâm not saying I should never be lynched.
Iâm saying I should never be lynched today.
Big difference
I donât like this argument. When are you ever more than 50% on anybody to be Scum? Unless theyâre really bad at the game. However, Iâm not the veteran here so I donât want to be arguing about the strength of particular roles and whatnot. What I do see is that thereâs some precedent for Scum trying to bus each other in this game. Nanook was buddying certain players and clearly attacking others. It would not be ridiculous for Nanook to have attacked you and I and think that it would deflect attention away from us (and make us look âTownierâ) and onto other players. Two of which are clearly Urist and Mantis. So Iâm perfectly okay with letting people lynch amongst us because we certainly have a few tries before we lose. The fact that you are so against it is revealing, in that you seem to have more at stake than I do. And thatâs not good.
1 Like