Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

[Mental (Judge)]

we did chat a bit in the temple QT last night, that helped.
i’d also be very interested to hear what happened after Josh stole from Judge, who I assume is Quark (Ishka’s son).

…I assume you mean you think Josh is Quark.

I am nog, VT aligned with the prophets.

[Urist]

Nah I assumed Quark because he is the son of Ishka (Josh’s character). Nog is Ishka’s grandson so I was close!

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I am aligned with the Wormhole Entities. Or as the Bajorans would rather call them, the Prophets.

[Urist]

Also I’m a racecop who learned you were Ferengi last night.
I was blocked n1 sadly.

[Urist]

ur mom is a wormhole entity ha ha ha

[Urist]

I guess that only leaves @MetalSonic

[Mantis]

Who was this to? Andres?

[Srceenplay]

Are you saying you are a race cop and iirc you said yesterday it’s not worth mass claiming race?

[Urist]

it was to judge.

[Urist]

yeahhh i don’t think my role is useful. I also wanted a chance to prove it before massclaim.
It’s also why I don’t think there’s an alignment cop around / why I disbelieve pyx’s claim (and still do).

[Srceenplay]

Ya that just makes me want to flip you more.

[Urist]

there aren’t gonna be any other investigatives bucko, so you’re kinda stuck believing my claim if you want to make your own claim believable.

[Srceenplay]

I can hold out hope for ms who didn’t want protection

[Srceenplay]

Otherwise lynch the miller

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

Hahaha I wish.

[Mental (Judge)]

there aren’t gonna be any other investigatives

if so

lynch the miller

yep
VOTE: pyx

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I’m interested to know why you thought this. So I was bussing my Scum buddy D1?

[Mantis]

I actually didn’t have time to look at your iso much so I guess that probably accounted for it too.

[pyx]

Well, there’s a reason I was so skeptical of Screenplay’s claim yesterday:

Summary

I’m a doc. I visited pyx last night.

I’m not a traditional doc in that when I visit someone I also show up to any invests that target my target.

So my think was, visit the Miller and if there is a role cop they should target miller night 1. Seeing me and miller potentially clearing us both and then having a 3 person town block.

I mean… if the day is ending soon, and he thought it might swing outside of MS/cabd. Then it makes sense kinda

No, it doesn’t. It looks no better than the first Screenplay claim.

My role says if anyone I target is target by invest the invest will also receive info on me.

So as soon as he claimed miller I thought, this is a perfect combo.

Screenplay also sort of opens with a Nanook vote (1st serious vote). I read the, “Fake”, “Fake”, “Fake” as townish. And then there’s the push-back on the Scum!Nanook agenda of tunneling cats, claiming a false inno read there. If it’s all scum theatre they’re having a jolly good time, but pushing cats to vote Nanook looks sincere. The claim of a Nanook scum slip that Urist says isn’t is immediately claimed as simply a dramatic affect, but he goes on to stand by his scum read of Nanook. But then he goes on to vote half the field, saying he doesn’t even remember his push on Nanook. By POE he has mid-D1 lynch list of Nanook, MS, or Judge and stays pretty conisient there. He goes from voting MS on the strength of Josh’s meta read there, to voting Mantis for quickly reversing course on MS over nothing, then joins the cabd wagon, then the smilodon wagon just to get a lynch.

After Nanook kill, Screenplay starts D2 with Judge and Mantis as prime targets, claiming to have caught Nanook. Votes MS.

He does say ahead of the Doc claim that he visited me. I still don’t know that I trust him. I think he’d be OK voting Judge, Mantis, MS, or Urist.

I only know that whether he’s believable or not, I’d rather not vote a town PR claim, and I guess it’s only he and I who have strong doubts on Urist.

It needs cleared up.

VOTE: MS

I’m leaning more of a urist and ms team.

See, that’s what I thought, before you showed up and claimed WeirdDocWhoGetsInvestigatedWithHisDocTarget and claims to have protected our Miller for the strangest reasons on Earth, and before I iosed and brought up the Urist posts I have.

What’s your character name claim, please?

So if a Rolecop of either alignment investigates your target they’ll get a result of your role?

And if an Alignment Cop investigates your target they’ll get your true alignment, that of your target and yourself, or will you be read as the alignment of your target? Or do you know which?

I’m just thinking there are a lot of Town PR claims for 2 measly scum. And as such it maybe makes the possession thing more feasible, and I’d almost expect investigative roles on both sides; OR, if it’s far simpler and direct as Josh suggests, and one of cabd or MS are being false, then too the complexity of what roles have been claimed are suspect as being not all of Town.

And still, there’s a reason I came in today ready to vote Screenplay and then paused.:

Well I came in today ready to vote Screenplay, but I don’t see mafia laying off a kill when they’re pretty decimated.

And I could see a Doc laying off MS after MS twice telling them NOT to protect there last night. So if he IS a Doc, that would seem to increase his chances of successfully targeting who mafia was most worried about.

I doubted Screenplay’s Doc claim becase with mafia flips of a Goon and a 2-shot Roleblocker, the Doc claim seemed to me a bit redundant, because of my protector role. But I did NOT prevent last night’s kill (which I still think mafia would have attempted), so there being whatever Screen is makes some sense.

I targeted my strongest Town read after yesterday - Mantis, with my shot as protecting a player targeted for a kill by dying instead of them - what we commonly call a Bodyguard, though no name is given to my role. I appear guilty if investigated for alignment (Miller), and I have 2 shots to die instead of a kill-targeted player (Bodyguard).

Now, it’s already been said in the game that our GM doesn’t give Millers additional powers, but here we are, so you have to decide if you believe me or not. And I’m likely puzzled to death, because I think maybe I still believe Screenplay. If his claim of targeting me night before last is true I can at least confirm that he’s NOT some weird recruitment parasite thingie. But I also have still very much expected there to be a regular ol’ alignment Cop, and for that Cop to be Town.

And with all the claims of Town stuff floating around mafia must have something besides a simple Godfather.

[pyx]

Again, with 2 mafia gone and no kill last night I think we have plenty of leeway to lynch me today if we think that brings clarity, esp. as it’s better to sort the Miller before endgame.

I don’t fear def, I laff at def! Ha-ha, def, you dastardly thief of life.

But do we really think both the Theif claims would be Town?