Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

[Srceenplay]

I asked everyone to claim their race and no one would do it but you want my character?

[Urist]

Yes, if your character doesn’t fit the claim at all, your claim will be unbelievable.
Like if you claimed your character was Worf I would vote you for sure.

[Urist]

I think we should lynch josh. He is full of it with “I have never read me wrong”. He did that in chosen mafia too @andres to try to lynch me and he turned out to be scum. Caught by the magnificent (and now dead) MUFFINA (also known as _fferyllt). It would explain why MUFFINA died last night so early.

He did do that in Chosen as scum, but he was calling you town the whole game, which you were. So he was technically not wrong.

[pyx]

Attn cabd voters, So y’all are thinking the skitter argument with Nanook over mass claiming was staged, and that this post from skitters is insincere:

@nanook:

i think he had a valid point in that you’ve been taking potshots with him and calling him scummy for trumped up reasons (the ‘excuse to move a vote’ thing ) without voting him

yes of course you can have more than one scumread at a time but you seem to be pushing him and nitpicking everything he says. like the things you’re focusing on don’t seem very scummy to me but you’re highlighting them and casting him a negative light; that’s what i was trying to get at with the other post

like i get that you think the claim is stupid and pointless, and you’re calling him out on that, but you aren’t actually pushing him as being scummy for doing so

Though I agree that skitter then seems to waffle in poking cats vote on Nanook.

cats voted nanook at screen’s behest because nanook was questioning screen’s claim and defended the claim as being true since it’s something that scum would be unlikely to fake and that were was no scum motivation for doing so (#284)

so i don’t really understand why cats would vote there upon the revelation that it was probably fake

But then she’s back to grilling Nanook:

@nanook:

or this is another example of what i was trying to say before - you’re taking potshots at [Screenplay] for doing something stupid but you aren’t really explicitly calling him scummy for it or wanting to lynch him so i feel like you’re just trying to shade him

And then, when Cabd takes over he comes in with what I’ve said was a very reasonable reads list (though some have called it safe – wink, wink, Urist), and then ‘follows’ _fferyllt (who didn’t actually have a vote down, and Cabd already puts Nanook as his #1 scum) onto Scum!Nanook with a vote (later changed to Josh).

Mostly caught up.

Town

{Andres, Parsec}

{Dan, Urist}

{Screenplay, Josh, Smileodon}

{Catspurr, Metal, Mantis}

{Nanook}

Not Town

Alternate Universe where the only innocents are bodies after every other player is confirmed not to be a death godfather-maker:

{_fferythemuffin}

Muffin, can you give me a “scumreading dan for dummies, second edition” guidebook? Because I don’t see what you seem to be seeing.

Cabd even tries to bribe Urist to vote Nanook. So if cabd is mafia all of that would have to be staged.

You have no vote out at present. Can you be bribed to join the wagon for the low low price of three easy payments of $19.99?

I agree that starting D2 with the Tracker claim, Cabd does a bit of a dive for me, esp. in that ALL of the claims have NOT been hard, but soft, even though Screenplay is claiming his as hard - it’s NOT. No flavour claims whatsoever, just bit-by-bit mechanic claims. But does a Scum!cabd really confuse or convolute the Miller claim based on Screenplay’s use of “Mason” in the middle of pressing MS as visiting _fferyllt?

I completely agree Cabd needs to get back in here, but y’all really think it’s a scum absence?
And look, someone has to be scum. EVERYONE has positives and negatives, and maybe VCA and Nanook associatives aren’t enough for this group of mindtwisters. I’m just still at a place where if I HAD to choose between MS and Cabd, well…

And pfft! It’s gonna get me nothin’ but grief, plain as the nose on my face, may have already, but I’m just not ready to jump right in on believing another Screenplay claim out of nowhere, not when I had just finally decided he could be town. Now I don’t know, What is the info we’re supposed to have gotten, just more investigative support of the Miller claim? Why give mafia yet another PR target over that?

[Mental (Judge)]

I swear to god, this game

UNVOTE: cabd

[Urist]

Why would you fakeclaim cop and say this

There is not going to be a cc.

If you know there are investigators? And with a Miller already claimed? This seems a little sketchy to me.

[Mental (Judge)]

VOTE: MS

[Mental (Judge)]

I’m not shifting my vote unless I do

[pyx]

And I’ve had Josh as a questionmark and maybe still do. For those who know Majiffy he kinda reminds me of Majiffy (he’s not Majiffy, btw, is he?). Josh hasn’t (been able) to play much, but has had it as Urist & MS since way back. He says MS never really challenged cabd on the Tracker claim as Josh would have expected, just accepted Cabd as town. But then he maybe buys into the possession thing a bit and says they both seem scummy.

There’s not much there at all between Josh and Scum!Nanook which is troubling. But I kinda like how Josh has offered to be more tollerant and accepting of flatearthers and those of us sensitive to abusive sass, barbs, mockings, nauseating denigrations, befoulments, vituperance, and ignominious tautings of the third kind.

I guess I could vote there, but it’s weaksauce.

[pyx]

Screenplay also sort of opens with a Nanook vote (1st serious vote). I read the, “Fake”, “Fake”, “Fake” as townish. And then there’s the push-back on the Scum!Nanook agenda of tunneling cats, claiming a false inno read there. If it’s all scum theatre they’re having a jolly good time, but pushing cats to vote Nanook looks sincere. The claim of a Nanook scum slip that Urist says isn’t is immediately claimed as simply a dramatic affect, but he goes on to stand by his scum read of Nanook. But then he goes on to vote half the field, saying he doesn’t even remember his push on Nanook. By POE he has mid-D1 lynch list of Nanook, MS, or Judge and stays pretty conisient there. He goes from voting MS on the strength of Josh’s meta read there, to voting Mantis for quickly reversing course on MS over nothing, then joins the cabd wagon, then the smilodon wagon just to get a lynch.

After Nanook kill, Screenplay starts D2 with Judge and Mantis as prime targets, claiming to have caught Nanook. Votes MS.
He does say ahead of the Doc claim that he visited me. I still don’t know that I trust him. I think he’d be OK voting Judge, Mantis, MS, or Urist.

I only know that whether he’s believable or not, I’d rather not vote a town PR claim, and I guess it’s only he and I who have strong doubts on Urist.

[Mantis]

I dont actually write it in the thread but the last several times I voted I’ve told myself that this is it

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

Cabd has been prodded.

[MetalSonic]

really? cos i swear he was trying to mislynch me

[MetalSonic]

i play: Chosen Mafia

[MetalSonic]

i really think we should lynch josh

[Mantis]

VOTE: josh

[MetalSonic]

VOTE: josh

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

VC 2-21

Metal Sonic: 3 (Josh, catspurr, Judge Mental)
Cabd: 1 (Metal Sonic)
Josh: 1 (Mantis)
Judge Mental: 1 (Srceenplay)

Not voting: 4 (pyx, Cabd, Urist, Andresvmb)

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: August 25, 2018 4:00 AM

This topic will close automatically 30 minutes after the deadline.

Mod Notes:

Links
Day 1 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 2 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!

[Urist]

VOTE: Josh

[MetalSonic]

catspurr and judgemental need to unvote me and get on the good wagon

catspurr has been idle since i last was online so thats fine