Judge isn’t scum
what’s your case here?
no case. Just more of an inkling like… maybe this IS the way to go?
I don’t really trust my reads this game. so it’s ALL up in the air!
yeah, me too
thing is, with MS, if we mislynch, I’ll really be annoyed with myself
same with CABD
I’d have happily voted screen before they claimed but…
thing is with a Josh lynch, a) if he flips town then what if he’s right about his read on MS (and his logic on likelihood of roles and actions aligning like that, is something I agree with) and b) this would start to feel like the smilodon lynch, for me at least
no, the smilodon lynch was an emergency lynch. that i wasnt on.
this josh lynch is endorsed by metal sonic. thats the big differenxe
1 Like
Well. the thing is, we shouldn’t feel bad about flipping anyone. Because it will give us info. It’ll make the puzzle easier to solve. Let’s not feel bad. (I say this, and have just unvoted because of emotional appeal). Hrmmm.
Who would you feel less bad about lynching? gun to head, kind of question.
1 Like
I think for me, it would be cabd. Even if he’s town. Flip em! He’s done nothing.
1 Like
I also realize that I might not be the greatest judge of reading people at the moment. But I don’t really care, and I think we need to get a lynch in to get more info.
VOTE: cabd
andres could be scum
Heh
Same VOTE: cabd
Yes
What info does his lynch give us for catching scum ?
no… maybe not. But yes, let’s vote cabd. he needs to go
VC 2-21
Metal Sonic: 2 (Josh, catspurr)
Cabd: 2 (Mantis, Judge Mental)
pyx: 1 (Andresvmb)
Josh: 1 (Metal Sonic)
Judge Mental: 1 (Srceenplay)
Not voting: 3 (pyx, Cabd, Urist)
With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
Deadline: August 25, 2018 4:00 AM
This topic will close automatically 30 minutes after the deadline.
Mod Notes: 
Links
Day 1 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 2 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
nah, I had for a second where I thought maybe he was. That passed pretty quickly. Let’s take it one step at a time. I’m tired of over thinking it too much. Perhaps Josh and cabd could work?
You do realise your entire mafia standing hinges on your read of Urist, don’t you?
No pressure 
Hmm that would actually work.
Noo… what do you mean? I know he has MS as town… that IS hinging into things I suppose… But also MS Ate also comes very much into play. even more so than Urist’s read on him.
Yes it could. Pyx seems better to me now. Screen is town (believe is claim). Urist said to me earlier about how he would be disappointed if I thought he were scum (kind of hit me as real). Cats is very likely town. Doesn’t leave that many people now, does it?
I just edited now to know