I don’t necessarily think so. I don’t think he has to be screaming over MS lynch. He could be calmly trying to pass it off. The waffling over it being not a kill on ffery, makes me wonder if he knows MS is town, and doesn’t want to go 1 v 1 on him, by claiming that he’s guilty.
I’m not sure. I’ll have to read it again. But I’m left with an unsettled feeling on how he went about it.
I’m fine with either. And I agree with your logic. So yeah.
So we just leave them alone?
yea but why would he bother faking a tracker guilty on MS if he didn’t wanna go 1v1 on him? Makes zero sense. Faking a guilty on a guy kind of carries the implication that you’re gonna go mono a mono.
Did you end up rereading to see why Nanook left, after voting cabd? or, if he left ?
No but maybe it’s true. Maybe he did track him (as scum tracker). But if he is scum, he would know that MS is town. So instead of going after his lynch, he’s just sort of poking at him instead.
…Which makes scum tracker a possibility , given all these town roles.
Also, Pyx voted for me earlier (it didn’t get picked up) by saying that Parsec had the game right, when he had me at the bottom and Nanook as most Town.
I am moving away from evaluating the slot from the point of view of the Miller claim, and I just don’t like what I’m seeing.
Honestly, if Cabd is scum, it’s far more likely that he’s the guy who messed with MS’s sleep schedule last night and blocked/redirected/whatevered him. Doesn’t make a ton of sense to block AND track the same guy as scum.
And this^ is the thing that makes me think maybe Cabd isn’t scum. We have what looks like a town fruit vendor. We have what looks like a scum blocker/redirector/track-framer/etc. It would make sense to have a town tracker in there right?
inb4 “don’t try to outguess the mod”
Not yet.
MS has looked questionable enough to have a redirect on him…
So with redirector:
A Redirector is a role that causes all actions taken on a particular Night by a specific player to target a specific second player instead of whatever their original target was.
So there are 2 targets involved. Could a town director target someone who they thought was very much town (and likely to draw the night kill) and target MS as the player to take it instead.
Could be a town role
Scum doesn’t need a tracker to say someone went to the kill.
You’re still thinking of Bus Driver.
A Redirector would force MS to target _fferyllt, regardless of who MS wanted to target. So if MS is a Fruit Vendor and targets Judge, but the Redirector redirects him to _fferyllt, _fferyllt would get the fruit and MS would be seen targeting him.
A Bus Driver would force anyone trying to target MS to actually target [SCUMFRIEND A], and vice-versa. So if MS is a Fruit Vendor and targets Judge, and Cabd is a tracker who targets MS, and Nanook is a goon who kills _fferyllt, what happens is 1. Judge gets her fruits, 2. Nanook kills _fferyllt, 3. Cabd tracks Nanook to _fferyllt (but may be told something ambiguous like “your target visited _fferyllt”, making him think that MS targeted _fferyllt).
ha. I copied from wiki.
But do you see what I am saying with potential to be a scum tracker?
I guess if there is a town bus driver who bussed MS and Nanook, it would make sense for Cabd to be a scum tracker, yes. I don’t really find that likely, though.
I also find Cabd’s handling of the situation to be townish. I agree that he could be scum tracker, but I don’t feel like his play indicates that.
I see.
I know what a bus driver is though.
Anyway - just wondering if a town redirector could fit into the picture.
Judge, Urist, Andres, cats <- I feel are town
Scum in here prob
Josh (I’ve thought he was town, but am not as certain as the town list above)
pyx (miller claim still looks okay, and parsec seemed fine)
Cabd
MS
Screenplay
So if MS and cabd are taken out of the picture, leaves:
pyx, Screen and Josh (which actually was your lynch list from before).
See above on re my thoughts on pyx and Josh. Unless I am just wrong there. But I have a hunch that they could be town, so it leads me to believe there IS scum within MS and cabd.
I guess I have to sort out whether I think Josh and pyx really are town.
CABD and MS? I’m going to, yes.
cats and pyx? enough people are town reading cats that he is likely safe. Pyx - last thing I’m saying on this topic but his gaslighting is scummy. I’ve caught him as scum before for doing this and I’m getting p good at it. I’ve done full disclosure though, re my issue with his playstyle in general, to be as fair as I can be to that slot.
lol oops, I assume you were replying to my ‘would and wouldn’t lynch’ list post. Carry on… 