This sounds like either I was redirected or roleblocker
…so your full claim is…?
sounds like we have to lynch one of you or I could be being dumb however these are not mutually exclusive
This is fair, though that would have been counterbalanced by the very many things that you raised throughout the game up to that point. Thus, I would have just expected that you would have maybe hedged your position a little more?
This is partly true, in that Nanook was willing to discuss other reads and players (clearly), though he always seemed to get stuck and revert back to his Scum read of Cats.
I can see 3. I have to say, I fell a bit for this myself.
You two are the only two players to almost assume that Nanook was Town in casting your views of the game D1. Srceen, on the other hand, seemed to consistently cast shade on the slot but never pushed him too hard (and Nanook never actually seemed to care to vote for Srceen despite Srceen placing a vote on him at one point). Given that the two of you have at various other times been pushing for Srceen as a target, I would be truly surprised if none of you flipped Scum.
why do you want to know, scum? is that your avatar speaking?
I want to know if I should lynch you for other reasons beside my av
I hate this whole Cabd v. MS saga. MS’ explanation could potentially explain Cabd’s result, which means that Cabd might have just placed an enormous target on his back. Also, if we lynch MS and MS flips Town, it does not tell us whether Cabd is lying. And if we lynch Cabd, and Cabd flips Town Tracker, it does not mean that MS is lying either. In fact, what makes it likely that they are both telling the truth is that Cabd would, as Scum, be taking quite the gamble if he argues that MS visited _fferyllt and MS knows this to be impossible. It basically sets a showdown and guarantees that 1 Scum sits between the two (and we would probably have gone for Cabd who was under significantly more pressure).
On the other hand, Cabd could have, together with his Scum Team, planned this whole thing. Say you take MS’ claim at face value. Since this is a role heavy game, the Scum Team could have simply targeted a player they thought they could make an easy target out of (that was to visit a player at night). So, they put a redirect on MS, and have whoever is under the most pressure claim Tracker and argue that MS visited whoever they decided to shoot. This way, MS would be unable to disprove Cabd’s claim convincingly, and if wrong, Cabd could still argue that it is not his fault.
Also, I can’t imagine that they are both Scum (it would be quite silly to be honest), so you have to think that at least one of them is telling the truth. I am more inclined to think that MS is being truthful, so I think I would be open to voting for Cabd. I, however, am not sure that it makes sense for the Town to do this today. I think we can wait to see if the Scum Team blinks first, and decides to eliminate one of them.
1 Like
Andre, your walls of text have got to the point that I honestly don’t know what any of your reads are.
Without waffling for several paragraphs, givng no explaination, please just list the alive players from most town to most scummy.
Thank You.
1 Like
VC 2-10
Judge Mental: 2 (Urist, Metal Sonic)
Metal Sonic: 1 (Srceenplay)
Srceenplay: 1 (Mantis)
Cabd: 1 (catspurr)
Not voting: 5 (Josh, pyx, Cabd, Andresvmb, Judge Mental)
With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
Deadline: August 25, 2018 4:00 AM
This topic will close automatically 30 minutes after the deadline.
Mod Notes: 
Links
Day 1 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
Day 2 Start: Deep Space 9 Mafia - Game Over!
lmao well played
VOTE: ms
@cabd so you said you tracked MS to ffery right? …tracked him to her corpse though? Is it looking like he was seen after she died? Or is it unclear?
MS visited _ffery; yes. When that is, I do not know. My results were not specific as to the time frame.
The way this is turningout, I think it likely that scum team has some sort of “reverse fruit vendor” or something? I don’t see myself voting for MS today. Or ever, really.
I don’t get it. You tracked MS to the dead guy. And MS refuses to claim, and doesn’t refute your claim at all. You don’t find that the least bit scummy…?
Not after your posting, no.
Which, as I sit here, I realize your posts AFTER the post I saw make what I thought incorrect, so never mind.
Let me re-read with that context out of the way.
why would i be scummy when i am obviously town and cabd is the scummy one?
if a scummy person claims that a towny person is scum, does that make the towny person scum?
?_?
I don’t get it. Isn’t the simpler conclusion that MS made the nightkill on ffery ?
if scum are scared enough of my role that they decided to do something creepy to me/roleblock/redirect me then obviously im not going to claim to give them more info
why the fuck would i do that? how will it benefit town?
im towny, so i cant make the nightkill on ffery.
dont you think thats way too much of a coincidence. cabd the mr mcscummy coincidentally tracking me who coincidentally got redirected to ffery coincidentally on night 1?
Because MS its looking like you will have to be lynched. You were tracked doing something to ffery. And it wasn’t protect, since he’s dead. So… what else was it, if not a kill?