Cocktail Party Mafia OVER

Completed Games Completed Onsite
,
#1021

change the theme to OG Dark

#1022

Yes but what it reveals is that you made up a case. It’s not that your gut was wrong, or that you misread something. It’s that your conclusion was set before you had evidence. It’s why the fundamental piece of it (I saw Dusk do the same thing as Scum) was wrong. You wanted to say Dusk was Scum, so you came up with that nonsense.

1 Like
#1023

I wish I could say I can see where you’re coming from but I can’t

“Dusk is throwing out easy townreads like I remember him doing early last game” → checks last game and finds Dusk throwing out easy townreads → points it out in the thread

like that’s literally EXACTLY the process you’re describing

#1024

ggs

#1025

The worst part is, you somehow decided I was worth SR’ing for agreeing with someone that was pointing out your nonsense. I even went and showed you why.

#1026

If anyone’s wondering this right here is why I don’t bother making cases

#1027

okay starv

#1028

Yeah I know. But for those that don’t play with you hahaha somebody has to try and rally the troops.

1 Like
#1029

weren’t you the first one to point out I was misremembering the timing from the last game?

#1030

Because of course the guy you case doesn’t agree with you and you’ll never convince them they’re scum and they just post and post and post

I do my talking with my wagonmates and then I talk about it once they’re dead and can’t talk

#1031

Yes but I wasn’t the first one to point out that the posts you were comparing weren’t even similar in nature. Dwai did.

#1032

Ya I know you know

Trying to explain for the benefit of the others too

#1033

that’s a delivery thing though and I don’t think that’s particularly relevant

#1034

like if you wanna argue every player approaches every scum game with the exact same tone and mindset that’s your prerogative

#1035

What’s your point?

I think delivery is relevant. Emotional content is alignment indicative. It’s hard to get good at it I admit. But it’s the best way I have to figure out when a Town player is about to get executed incorrectly. It almost always gets emotional. You can feel it.

#1036

on the other hand people fall into habits of things they’re comfortable with

somebody who throws out a few clears as scum here is more likely to do it as scum there even if the manner in which they do it differs

#1037

:thinking:

#1038

this is confusing to me

your reasoning is

because imo the manner is almost all that matters tbh

#1039

Also Chess is either cleared Town or Scum by now. They’re too direct. And that read I know how to make.

#1040

not all that matters but like

idk man