Chosen - GAME OVER

[northsidegal]

enjoy being* scum.

wow i wish i could edit posts for typos.

[_fferyllt (_fferyllt (muffins > cupcakes))]

basically the whole voting me after alisae said that i prefer scum is just a really kind of strange (careless?) thing to do, and i typically imagine most people as scum to be more self-aware or hyperaware of everything that they’re doing

i don’t think metal sonic is that sort of scum player (hyperaware, meticulous, etc)

i do think that this probably came from him as town though

[MetalSonic]

what’s wrong with believing alisae after she said “trust me I am a very creditable source”

Somehow That’s a scummy thing??

[MetalSonic]

this seems OOG maybe you should interview me

[northsidegal]

what’s wrong with believing alisae after she said “trust me I am a very creditable source”

Somehow That’s a scummy thing??

why would you follow her on me specifically (someone who you had reason to believe prefers town) as opposed to anyone else who you know for a fact would be more likely to choose scum?

this seems OOG maybe you should interview me

trust me, i think it’s game relevant. just a short sentence or two?

[Alisae]

1. She likely picked scum
2. her scumhunting looks fake
3. She is a BIG FAT LIAR!!! D:

Ok
Lol
What a big fucking deal

[Alisae]

This isn’t likely its
I literally picked scum

[Katsuki]

If this is me doing nothing then you’ll love me more when I post nothing.

I hardly see how I’ve been sorting only those who are more likely to pick town. Keychain and ffery maybe, but you I know nothing about. This is also why I hate providing reads of any sort.

[Katsuki]

At this point I really hope you guys powerlynch muffin should I ever flip town at any point in the game.

[Alisae]

At this point I really hope you guys powerlynch muffin should I ever flip town at any point in the game.

I’m probs just over thinking things

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

i think your suspicion of me probably is genuine, even though it’s pretty dumb

don’t think you’d have the cupcakes to post that opening as scum tbh either, or at least if you did, i think you’d do it differently

i think your cupcake+alisae suspicion looks genuine enough too

and there’s various smaller things that i think you probably aren’t doing as scum

I had a thought at dinner. I was imagining a scum-topic convo between metal sonic and alisae about how to look not-like-a-team.

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

whoever is town in {eddie,nsg,alisae,cupcake} should start being town imo

could you describe why these people specifically?

Different reasons for different players. And key should have been in that group.

Eddie’s first post or three felt empty to me, like there was nothing evaluative going on.

I don’t remember why I called you out. I think I might have intended to put Key in that group rather than you, because I wanted to see more posts from her.

alisae’s posts have also felt kind of empty - like it’s all positioning and no testing or evaluating, except for the thing about you choosing scum. And katsuki’s countertrolling of muffin gave me no alignment vibes at all. There are some stances there, but I don’t get a sense that he believes them.

zmuffin and metal sonic have stances, which is something, at least. I don’t expect either of them to be easy to read here.

And Andres is a townread.

[Key]

Okay where did my blimming post just go

While I recompile - ffery, do you normally seek out townreads or scumreads first?

[Key]

Also you responding to that post confused me to an embarrassing degree.

though speaking of which, this is another point about cupcake. there’s a decent chance cupcake is scum but on the off-chance he’s actually anti town, i am almost certain that scum would absolutely be trembling in fear at cupcake’s ability to both look obvtown and find and push scum lynches, so it’s a fair assumption that scum chose cupcake to not be chosen, ergo the best lynch choice

… this is tenuous at best! Is it supposed to be tenuous at best?

Let’s see what have I gathered so far. I obviously don’t have any good reads, since there’s a bunch of posturing going on.

What do you mean by posturing, and why would it mean you obviously don’t have any good reads? I don’t quite follow.

sorry I’m not playing mafia for the next few days

I hope everything’s all right

I prefer a MS lynch currently because I don’t believe I can get a D1 lynch off on muffin but he is likely scum given his play thus far.

I’m starting to lean this way on muffin too, though it could be that the high joke content puts me on edge.

[Andresvmb (Andrés)]

I have been trying figure out what to do with my vote. So I went back and read through some of the postings to see who is saying what. This isn’t easy without a whole lot of information beyond the initial votes.

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

Okay where did my blimming post just go

While I recompile - ffery, do you normally seek out townreads or scumreads first?

It depends on how a game develops, but I’d say my tendency is to see if I can lock in some town reads in the early game if possible, and then continue to reevaluate and test my impressions.

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

My god I just realized I answered a question about a post that muffin made, thinking I had made it.

I’m so trolled.

[Katsuki]

You never think I believe my stances though, it was the same thing in Resistance.

[fferyllt (fairlylit)]

Are we supposed to be casting aspersions this freely btw?

And if the scum players are experienced, so be it.

No we’re all cops and we no lynch to go into night and peek someone because hunting off of what people post in a game is ridiculous and blasphemy no one can ever read into posts you have to have hard proof to accuse someone of being mafia

Harsh

[Katsuki]

I’m starting to lean this way on muffin too, though it could be that the high joke content puts me on edge.

His joke content is usually quite high - which is why he’s so enjoyable to play with - but his jokes this game have been geared at subtly discrediting me as a player
and painting me in a scummy light.