11p Arsonists (1, 7)

  1. why did you not vote him if you thought he was powerscumming?
  2. how is lying down to a lynch powerscumming?
  3. why is he now exempt from your vote/suspicion?

VOTE: GTacc

scum

gtacc

starv
killthestory

andres
duskfall
josh

nanook
m2h
actiondan

town

is that now or the elli list?

you’re really reading a lot into a post i put exactly 2 seconds of effort into, aren’t you?

1: the follow up ā€˜lol let me add vote’ from gtacc and crew was even scummier
2: it could be AtE. if i’d have thought about it for more than 2 seconds before firing off the post i would have realized josh wouldn’t need to resort to doing so
3: he’s not

ellilist

i just caught up on all of today’s posts so my reads haven’t significantly changed yet

The thing I suspected about Josh is he said I am town then voted me 3 posts later. You know self preservation and stuff but idk

I keep waffling on my dusk read but I think this is basically where I’m at, yeah. I don’t feel super great about it though, tbh.

Sort of feel like I want to sort tn/gtacc first after that last 30ish post stretch. A gtacc ā€œmaybe laterā€ and tn that doesn’t seem to have his shit together in a weird way (as opposed to the usual way)…I think I’m probably more comfortable sorting that bucket first.

Inclination says gtacc first for reasons that aren’t super kind—if one is town, I’d rather have scatterbrained but trying tn around than scatterbrained and absent gtacc. I feel sort of icky about saying it but there it is anyways.

VOTE: gtacc

It would be nice if gtacc or tn could obvs town and make the decision easier but I’m not holding my breath rn.

I don’t feel super great about my reads… The logical conclusion is that it’s someone who I can usually easily scum read :thinking:

Did I get that about right Nanook?

I mean, this is such bullshit given that Josh was 2 seconds away from being lynched… If someone is the leading wagon with less than 5 seconds left in the day, you can’t say they don’t have to resort to X in order to survive.

Not to mention the thread was dead, you, DS and GTacc were all afk when it started.

Nanook too

Ellis not in the game so I guess we can’t lynch properly. Going for gtacc then setting up tn for tomorrow is obvious mislynch bait. You guys really need to learn to not just sheep good players every time because you just auto lose when they are scum.

Anyways think scum team is likely Josh and nanook atp but they won’t be lynched until after they lead a few more mislynch ig

Like, I’m fine with people town reading Josh… But don’t town read him for something ā€œhe doesn’t have to doā€ when the situation was very dire AND you can argue the same about town!Josh not having to go down that road…

But if he doesn’t he gets lynched 10/10.

I don’t think Nanook is scum

He’s defending Josh too hard for no reason

Except for the one scumslip, I wouldn’t say gtacc is easy to scumread, more that he’s easy to TR sometimes :woman_shrugging:

Me and josh have history fwiw, so not ā€œno reason.ā€