Because I think scum!dusk would try to come up with some kind of association to push a read. I agree that he comes off tonally scummy overall but the fact that he isn’t trying to push something gives me pause.
Tn comes off flakey and it seems kinda like he also wants to pocket me and josh. He literally still hasn’t even tried to defend starv being his top scum read even though he said it was a policy lynch because starv is “dumb town” as if that has anything to do with his alignment.