[Game Thread] SFM1 - Puella Magi Forum★Mafia: Rebellion

That was a reads list! But I will explain my reads! The sharp disagreement on reads is part of why I don’t trust you! I also felt like being evasive about the neighborhood is weird play if you are town no matter what you think about the other two!

bepwei, the hydra, and deadbananas I don’t have reads, so scum lean for that!

Quin I talked about on N1 and D1! I don’t like that their N1 was very low content!

gellnick was on the fringe for me! I don’t have enough of a read to sr but I was starting to get there partly on consensus!

Nibio/Wisp had a bad start to N1 but got better over time! I still feel like they had an affected tone early on! They felt more natural in back-and-forth, but I will see if interaction analysis gets anywhere!

From past reading of Marshal and Zone, both seemed to be natural, but will need comparisons! Zone plays to his scumgame and Marshal is very scary!!!

Ari I don’t know very well but I’ve liked a lot of what I’ve seen! Something pinged my gut though I don’t remember what it was!

Squirrel oozed town from every pore! Not much more to say there!

Alison I got to a tr eventually! She does not appear to have an agenda! She will get a reread much later! For now I trust her!

Arete looked firmly to be naive town when I thought it was a neighbor chat! I believe that it is a mason chat for now and I still have a hard tr on Arete!

Ash has been solving from the beginning! I was confusing them with Ari for a while, but I separated them and Ash is the beautiful one of the two!

REM oozed town with more spread but less blatantness than Squirrel! If REM is scum, I will eat an entire raw eggplant on camera after the game!

bepwei, Ari, Eric, Marshal, gellnick are getting rereads in some order, followed by the hydra and deadbananas!

what did you want me to address here? Sure I have done some weird plays in the past and Meta is probably a terrible way to read me (but go ahead). I am not really understanding your argument here for me and I stand by everything I have said so far.

help me good peoples how does one do VCs

I’m like 64% sure we just request it in our own

1 Like

So… you do not like that I have a life and that on our recovery day I was more inactive than usual.

You don’t

Votecount as of post #193

Icibalus (3): Arete, ash4fun, Marshal
EricKline (1): Zone_Q11
Arete (1): Ari_2412
IronicDeadBird (1): Wisp
bepwei (1): Geyde

Not Voting (10): REM, bepwei, IronicDeadBird, Quin, EricKline, Icibalus, Valerie, Chemist1422, deadbananas, TotallyNotKyubey

I wasn’t asking you to address anything

1 Like

We did get a mech green check on bewpei at the start of N2 so if you want to make that say anything.

Personally I do not fully trust it but it is something to consider.

i’m confused about what this means… if i’ve got the story straight, aren’t you supposed to be able to take someone’s role? in that case, you either did or didn’t - i don’t see these options.

-sunbell (someday i’ll remember to sign my posts without an edit)

Wait what
Link?

i believe it’s this?

2 Likes

Jeez I remembered that as a mod confirm town not a message

This gives some food for thought

There was two roles available and the ability for me to wait during D1 (useless’s and GKB’s and not picking a role and waiting a day)

Does your ability allow you to switch roles, or do you have to stick to what you have chosen for the whole game?

I already told you that it’s about quality, not quantity! I think your posts were not trying hard to sort! I don’t care how many posts you made or when you made them!

REM! I missed you! How are you?!

1 Like

I’m good! What about you!?

Great! I’m enjoying some local fried chicken right now!

Can you talk to me about gellnick?! Icibalus is slightly town for me in a vacuum, but I’m just starting my reread!

That sounds really good!!

I don’t have much of an opinion on gellnick right now but I remember reading through Arete’s case on him and thinking it was good! I don’t remember a lot from him though!