No kill is always the play in this game, because whether you are at 3 or 4, it’s still LyLo… The difference is, at 4 it’s technically 1/3 and at 3, it’s technically 50/50… I mean, effectively, due to roles and claiming, it’s going to be 50/50 either way, but with 4 players, you get to better select your battle (assuming it wasn’t already established day 1)…
Town should force the 1v1s day 1… So, if town successfully does that, then it doesn’t really matter I guess… I would still go for 4p over 3p LyLo because there’s more opportunity for chaos.